Breakdown of Segundo a planilha, a despesa variável cresce.
Questions & Answers about Segundo a planilha, a despesa variável cresce.
Why does segundo mean according to here? I thought it meant second.
In this sentence, segundo is being used as a preposition, and it means according to.
- Segundo a planilha = According to the spreadsheet
- o segundo capítulo = the second chapter
So the same word can have different meanings depending on how it is used.
A few examples:
- Segundo o relatório, as vendas caíram. = According to the report, sales fell.
- Ela chegou em segundo lugar. = She arrived in second place.
In your sentence, segundo is definitely the according to meaning.
Why is it a planilha and a despesa variável? What does a mean in each case?
Both a words here are the definite article the.
- a planilha = the spreadsheet
- a despesa variável = the variable expense
Portuguese uses definite articles more often than English does, so seeing a or o is very normal.
Here, both nouns are feminine singular:
- planilha is feminine singular, so it takes a
- despesa is feminine singular, so it also takes a
If the nouns were masculine, you would use o:
- o relatório
- o custo variável
What exactly does planilha mean? Is it always a spreadsheet?
Usually, yes. Planilha most commonly means spreadsheet, especially in Brazilian Portuguese.
Common uses:
- planilha do Excel = Excel spreadsheet
- planilha financeira = financial spreadsheet
- planilha de custos = cost spreadsheet
Depending on context, it can sometimes be understood more broadly as a table or worksheet, but spreadsheet is the most natural meaning in modern Brazilian Portuguese.
What does despesa variável mean grammatically? Why does variável come after despesa?
Despesa variável is a noun + adjective combination:
- despesa = expense
- variável = variable
In Portuguese, adjectives often come after the noun, much more often than in English. So:
- despesa variável = variable expense
- custo fixo = fixed cost
- lucro líquido = net profit
That word order is normal and expected here.
Also, variável agrees in gender and number with the noun:
- feminine singular: despesa variável
- feminine plural: despesas variáveis
- masculine singular: custo variável
- masculine plural: custos variáveis
Why is it cresce and not está crescendo?
Cresce is the present indicative form of crescer and can mean:
- grows
- is growing
- sometimes even does grow, depending on context
So Portuguese often uses the simple present where English might use either the simple present or the present continuous.
Your sentence:
- a despesa variável cresce = the variable expense grows / is growing
If you say está crescendo, that puts stronger emphasis on an ongoing process happening right now.
Compare:
- A despesa variável cresce ao longo do ano. = The variable expense grows over the year.
- A despesa variável está crescendo rapidamente. = The variable expense is growing quickly.
In your sentence, cresce is perfectly natural.
What subject is cresce agreeing with?
It agrees with a despesa variável, which is third person singular.
So:
- a despesa variável cresce = the variable expense grows
The verb crescer in the present tense:
Because the subject is singular, the verb is singular: cresce.
Could I say Segundo a planilha, despesa variável cresce without the article?
In most normal Portuguese, a despesa variável sounds more natural and correct here.
- Segundo a planilha, a despesa variável cresce.
Leaving out the article:
- Segundo a planilha, despesa variável cresce.
This sounds less natural in standard everyday Portuguese. Portuguese usually likes an article before a common noun used as the subject, especially in a sentence like this.
So for a learner, it is best to keep a here.
Why isn’t there a pronoun like ela before cresce?
Portuguese often does not use subject pronouns when the subject is already clear.
Here, the subject is explicitly stated:
- a despesa variável cresce
You do not need:
- a despesa variável ela cresce
That would usually sound wrong or unnecessarily repetitive in this context.
Portuguese is a language where the verb form and sentence structure often make the subject clear enough without extra pronouns.
Is Segundo a planilha a complete clause?
No. Segundo a planilha is a prepositional phrase, not a full clause.
It gives the source of the information:
- According to the spreadsheet
The full sentence is:
- Segundo a planilha, a despesa variável cresce.
Structure:
- Segundo a planilha = source/frame
- a despesa variável cresce = main clause
This kind of opening phrase is very common:
- Segundo o jornal, haverá greve.
- Segundo os dados, a produção aumentou.
Can despesa variável also be translated as variable cost?
Sometimes, depending on context, but not always exactly.
- despesa usually means expense
- custo usually means cost
In business or accounting contexts, English sometimes uses cost and expense in ways that overlap, but Portuguese may choose one or the other more specifically.
So:
- despesa variável = variable expense
- custo variável = variable cost
If the original Portuguese says despesa, it is safest to understand it as expense unless the broader context suggests a more technical translation.
How is cresce pronounced in Brazilian Portuguese?
In Brazilian Portuguese, cresce is pronounced approximately like KRESS-see or KREH-see, depending on accent.
A rough breakdown:
- cre sounds like kreh
- sce often sounds like ssi in Brazilian Portuguese
So:
- cresce ≈ KREH-see
Also useful:
- despesa ≈ des-PEH-zah
- variável ≈ vah-ree-AH-vel
- planilha ≈ plah-NEEL-yah
These are only approximations for English speakers, but they can help.
Could the sentence order be changed?
Yes, but the original order is very natural.
Original:
- Segundo a planilha, a despesa variável cresce.
You could also say:
- A despesa variável cresce, segundo a planilha.
This still means the same thing, but it sounds a little different in rhythm and emphasis. The original version is especially common in formal or informational writing because it introduces the source first.
So both are possible, but the original is the most straightforward and neutral.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PortugueseMaster Portuguese — from Segundo a planilha, a despesa variável cresce to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions