Breakdown of Ten karton jest cięższy niż tamten, bo są w nim książki.
Questions & Answers about Ten karton jest cięższy niż tamten, bo są w nim książki.
Why is it ten karton and not ta karton or to karton?
What do ten and tamten mean here?
They are demonstratives:
- ten = this
- tamten = that
So the contrast is:
- ten karton = this box
- tamten = that one / that box
In this sentence, Polish is comparing two boxes: this one and that one.
Why can tamten stand by itself without repeating karton?
Because Polish often leaves out a noun when it is already clear from context.
So:
- Ten karton jest cięższy niż tamten.
literally means:
- This box is heavier than that one.
The word tamten already implies tamten karton. English does the same with that one.
Why isn’t there a word for the in this sentence?
Because Polish does not have articles like a and the.
Polish usually relies on:
- context
- word order
- demonstratives like ten, tamten
So ten does not just mean the. It is stronger, more like this.
If you simply wanted The box is heavy, Polish would usually just say:
- Karton jest ciężki.
What exactly does karton mean? Is it the same as English carton?
Not always exactly.
In this sentence, karton most naturally means a cardboard box or carton/packing box.
That is a little broader than English carton, which often suggests things like:
- a milk carton
- an egg carton
In Polish, karton can very naturally refer to a plain cardboard box used for packing or storing things.
Why is it cięższy? What form is that?
Cięższy is the comparative form of ciężki (heavy), so it means heavier.
Base adjective:
- ciężki = heavy
Comparative:
- cięższy = heavier
It also agrees with karton, which is masculine singular, so the masculine singular comparative form is used.
Why is it cięższy and not bardziej ciężki?
Because with this adjective, Polish normally uses the simple comparative:
- ciężki → cięższy
That is the normal, natural way to say heavier.
Using bardziej ciężki would sound unnatural in most everyday situations.
Polish does sometimes use bardziej + adjective, but mainly when:
- there is no simple comparative,
- or the speaker wants a special stylistic effect.
Here, cięższy is definitely the standard choice.
What does niż mean, and could I use something else?
Niż means than.
So:
- cięższy niż tamten = heavier than that one
Polish also often uses od after comparatives:
- Ten karton jest cięższy od tamtego.
Both are correct, but the grammar changes a little:
- after niż: tamten
- after od: tamtego (genitive form)
So both patterns are common:
- cięższy niż tamten
- cięższy od tamtego
Why is there jest in the first part but są in the second?
Because the verbs agree with different subjects.
Ten karton jest cięższy...
Subject: ten karton = singular
So: jest = is...bo są w nim książki.
Subject: książki = plural
So: są = are
Even though English might say because there are books in it, Polish still uses normal plural agreement with książki.
Why is it w nim? What does nim mean?
Nim means him/it after a preposition. Here it means in it.
The base pronoun is:
- on = he / it (for masculine nouns)
After the preposition w (in), the form changes:
- w nim = in him / in it
Here it refers back to karton, so:
- w nim = in it / inside it
This is just the normal Polish pronoun form used after prepositions.
What case is used in w nim?
Here w expresses location (in), so it takes the locative case.
That is why you get:
- w nim = in it
This is different from motion into something, where Polish may use a different structure.
So in this sentence:
- w nim książki = books in it
- not movement, just location
Why is the word order są w nim książki and not książki są w nim?
Polish word order is more flexible than English.
The sentence:
- bo są w nim książki
is very natural and has an existential feel, similar to English:
- because there are books in it
You could also say:
- bo książki są w nim
- bo w nim są książki
but the emphasis would shift a little.
The original version sounds natural because it presents the books as the explanation for why the box is heavier.
Why is it bo? Could I say ponieważ?
Yes. Bo means because and is very common in everyday Polish.
So:
- bo są w nim książki = because there are books in it
You could also say:
- ponieważ są w nim książki
That sounds a bit more formal or written.
Very roughly:
- bo = everyday, common, conversational
- ponieważ = more formal, more careful style
In normal speech, bo is usually the most natural choice.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PolishMaster Polish — from Ten karton jest cięższy niż tamten, bo są w nim książki to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions