Breakdown of Ona urodziła się w lipcu, a ja urodziłem się w listopadzie.
Questions & Answers about Ona urodziła się w lipcu, a ja urodziłem się w listopadzie.
Why are there two different verb forms: urodziła and urodziłem?
Because Polish past tense agrees with gender as well as person and number.
- ona urodziła się = she was born
- ja urodziłem się = I was born said by a man
- If the speaker were a woman, it would be ja urodziłam się
So in this sentence, ona refers to a female person, and ja is a male speaker.
Why is się used here?
In Polish, urodzić się is the normal way to say to be born.
So:
- urodzić by itself usually means to give birth to
- urodzić się means to be born
Even though się often looks like oneself, here you should learn urodzić się as a fixed expression meaning be born.
Why is it w lipcu and w listopadzie, not w lipiec and w listopad?
Because after the preposition w meaning in, the names of months take the locative case.
So:
- lipiec → w lipcu
- listopad → w listopadzie
This is just the normal pattern for months when saying in July, in November, etc.
Why does Polish use a here instead of i?
A often links two clauses with a slight sense of contrast or comparison.
So:
- Ona urodziła się w lipcu, a ja urodziłem się w listopadzie.
means something like:
- She was born in July, and I was born in November
- or She was born in July, whereas I was born in November
If you used i, it would sound more like simple addition. A is very natural here because the sentence compares her month with my month.
Why is there no separate word for was, like in English was born?
Can the pronoun ona be omitted?
Yes, very often.
Polish usually drops subject pronouns when they are clear from the verb form or the context. So you could say:
- Urodziła się w lipcu, a ja urodziłem się w listopadzie.
That is completely natural.
Including ona adds emphasis or contrast, especially because the sentence compares her and me.
Can ja also be omitted?
Sometimes yes, but here it is usually kept because it helps the contrast.
You could say:
- Ona urodziła się w lipcu, a urodziłem się w listopadzie.
and it could be understood, but it sounds less balanced. In a comparison like this, ja is very natural and usually preferred.
So in this sentence:
- ona = optional, often used for emphasis
- ja = also not strictly necessary, but very natural here
Why is urodziłem się different from urodził się?
Is urodzić się perfective or imperfective, and does that matter here?
Yes. Urodzić się is perfective, and that matters because being born is treated as a completed single event.
That is why Polish normally says:
- urodził się / urodziła się / urodziłem się
for was born.
There is also rodzić się, which is imperfective, but it is not the normal choice for a simple statement about someone’s date of birth. For this sentence, urodzić się is exactly right.
Can the word order change, for example Ona się urodziła w lipcu?
Yes. Polish word order is more flexible than English.
All of these can work:
- Ona urodziła się w lipcu
- Ona się urodziła w lipcu
The first version is probably the most neutral for many learners.
A useful rule is that się usually does not go at the very beginning of a clause.
So:
- Się urodziła... is not a normal way to begin the sentence
- but Ona się urodziła... is fine
How do I know whether to say urodziłem się or urodziłam się about myself?
Does w listopadzie mean in November in general or in the November of a specific year?
It simply means in November. Polish does not use articles like a or the, so the exact meaning comes from context.
In this sentence, it naturally means in the month of November when I was born. There is no need for an article in Polish.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PolishMaster Polish — from Ona urodziła się w lipcu, a ja urodziłem się w listopadzie to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions