Questions & Answers about Nie rozmawiaj z obcym.
Why is it rozmawiaj and not rozmawiać?
Because rozmawiaj is the imperative form: it means talk! / speak!
- rozmawiać = to talk / to converse (the dictionary form)
- rozmawiaj = talk! (command to one person, informal)
With nie, it becomes a negative command:
- Nie rozmawiaj = Don’t talk
So the sentence is giving an instruction, not just naming the action.
Who is being addressed here? Where is the word for you?
Polish usually does not need to say the subject pronoun if it is clear from the verb form.
In rozmawiaj, the ending already tells you this is a command to one person in the informal singular sense, so an English you is understood automatically.
So:
- Nie rozmawiaj = Don’t talk / Don’t talk you is not how Polish works
- The you is built into the verb form
Why is nie written separately?
Why is it z obcym and not z obcy?
Because the preposition z meaning with requires the instrumental case.
The adjective obcy changes form in the instrumental singular:
- obcy = basic form
- obcym = instrumental form
Since rozmawiać z kimś means to talk with someone, Polish uses:
- z + instrumental
So:
- z obcym = with a stranger / with a foreign person / with someone unknown
What exactly is obcym here?
Obcym is the adjective obcy used like a noun.
The adjective obcy can mean things like:
- strange
- foreign
- unknown
- unfamiliar
In this sentence, it means something like a stranger or an unknown person.
Polish often does this: an adjective can stand on its own when the noun is understood.
So z obcym is short for something like:
- z obcym człowiekiem = with a stranger / with an unknown person
- possibly z obcym mężczyzną depending on context, though here it is usually more general
Does obcy really mean stranger? I thought it meant foreign or alien.
Yes, that is a very good question. Obcy has a wider meaning than the English word stranger.
Depending on context, obcy can mean:
- foreign
- strange
- not one of us
- unknown
- a stranger
In Nie rozmawiaj z obcym, the natural meaning is Don’t talk to strangers or Don’t talk to a stranger.
So the exact English translation depends on context, but in a warning like this, obcy is understood as an unknown person.
Why is it z if English usually says talk to someone, not talk with someone?
Because Polish and English do not always use the same prepositions.
In Polish, the standard pattern is:
- rozmawiać z kimś = literally to talk with someone
English often says:
- talk to someone
- talk with someone
But Polish uses z here, not a direct equivalent of English to.
So even if the English meaning shown is Don’t talk to a stranger, the Polish structure is based on with:
- rozmawiać z kimś
Is this sentence singular or plural? Does it mean Don’t talk to a stranger or Don’t talk to strangers?
Grammatically, it is singular:
- z obcym = with a stranger / with an unknown person
So word-for-word it is singular.
However, in real usage, especially in warnings, Polish singular can sometimes express a general idea, much like English can say:
- Don’t talk to a stranger
- Don’t talk to strangers
Both can fit the general meaning, but the Polish form here is singular.
Is this addressed to a child, a friend, or anyone? Is it formal or informal?
It is informal singular.
That means it is said to one person using the ty form, for example:
- to a child
- to a friend
- to someone you address informally
It is not the formal version.
Possible alternatives:
- Nie rozmawiajcie z obcymi. = Don’t talk to strangers (informal plural)
- Proszę nie rozmawiać z obcymi. = Please do not talk to strangers (more formal / polite)
- Niech pan/pani nie rozmawia z obcymi. = formal singular
Why isn’t it Nie rozmawaj? How is rozmawiaj formed?
The imperative of rozmawiać is formed as rozmawiaj.
This is just the standard imperative pattern for many verbs ending in -ać:
- czytać → czytaj
- pytac would actually be pytać → pytaj
- rozmawiać → rozmawiaj
So rozmawiaj is the correct command form.
The -aj ending is very common in imperatives of this type.
Could I say Nie mów z obcym instead?
Not if you want the same natural meaning.
- rozmawiać = to have a conversation / to talk
- mówić = to speak / to say
In Polish, the normal verb for talk with someone is rozmawiać z kimś.
Mówić z kimś exists in some contexts or regional usage, but it is not the best standard choice here.
So:
- Nie rozmawiaj z obcym. = natural
- Nie mów z obcym. = not the usual standard way to say this
Would Nie rozmawiaj z nieznajomym also work?
Yes, and many learners notice this.
- nieznajomy = stranger / unknown person
- obcy = strange / foreign / unknown / outsider
In many contexts, nieznajomy is a very direct equivalent of stranger.
So:
- Nie rozmawiaj z nieznajomym. = also a natural sentence
The nuance is that obcy can feel a bit broader, while nieznajomy focuses more specifically on someone you do not know.
In warnings to children, both ideas are understandable, though the exact preferred wording may depend on context.
Does obcym tell us the gender of the stranger?
Formally, obcym is a masculine singular instrumental form, but in a sentence like this it is often understood more generically.
Polish often uses masculine forms in a general sense when the exact person is not specified.
If you specifically wanted to mention a woman, you would normally make that explicit:
- Nie rozmawiaj z obcą kobietą. = Don’t talk to a strange / unknown woman
But in Nie rozmawiaj z obcym, the idea is usually simply with a stranger, not necessarily with a male stranger only.
Is this a completed action or an ongoing one? Why is rozmawiać used and not a perfective verb?
Rozmawiać is imperfective, and that is normal here.
Negative commands often use the imperfective when you mean:
- don’t do this in general
- don’t start doing this
- don’t be doing this
So Nie rozmawiaj z obcym is a general prohibition:
Don’t talk to a stranger / Don’t talk to strangers.
A perfective partner is less central here because the point is not one completed conversation, but the general action of engaging in conversation.
Can this sentence sound natural on its own, or does it usually need context?
Yes, it can sound natural on its own, especially as a warning or instruction.
For example, a parent might say it to a child, or it might appear in safety advice.
Still, in real modern Polish, you might often also hear a plural generic version:
- Nie rozmawiaj z obcymi. = Don’t talk to strangers
That version can sound even more like a general rule.
But the singular sentence you were given is still grammatically correct and understandable.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PolishMaster Polish — from Nie rozmawiaj z obcym to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions