Breakdown of Buku itu disimpan di rak tinggi di ruang tamu.
Questions & Answers about Buku itu disimpan di rak tinggi di ruang tamu.
In Malay, demonstratives like ini (this) and itu (that) usually come after the noun:
- buku itu = that book / the book
- buku ini = this book
In many contexts, buku itu is best translated as the book, not necessarily that book.
Functionally:
- buku itu often marks the noun as specific/known (definite), similar to English the book.
- If you really want to emphasize physical distance (“that book over there”), context, pointing, or intonation usually does the job; the same itu is used.
So buku itu can be either the book or that book, depending on context, but the structure noun + itu is the normal order.
Disimpan comes from the root verb simpan (to keep / store / put away).
- simpan = to keep, store
- meN-
- simpan → menyimpan = to keep/store (active)
- di-
- simpan → disimpan = to be kept/stored (passive)
So disimpan is a passive or stative form:
- Buku itu disimpan… → The book is kept… / is being kept…
Malay often uses this di- passive form when:
- The agent (the doer) is unknown, unimportant, or obvious from context.
- You’re focusing on the thing and its state/location, not on who is doing the action.
No agent is stated here, so it just means the book is (kept/stored) somewhere, without saying by whom.
The agent (the person who keeps the book) is simply omitted. This is very common and natural in Malay.
You could add an agent:
- Buku itu disimpan oleh saya.
→ The book is kept by me.
But in everyday speech and writing, Malays often leave out both oleh and the agent when it’s not important:
- Buku itu disimpan di rak tinggi…
→ The book is kept on the high shelf… (no need to say “by who”)
So, the sentence is grammatically complete even without mentioning the doer.
In Malay, di appears in two very different roles:
As a preposition for location (always written separately):
- di rak = on/at the shelf
- di ruang tamu = in the living room
- di rumah = at home
Here, di is like English in / at / on.
As a passive verb prefix (written attached to the verb):
- disimpan = is kept / is stored
- ditulis = is written
- dibeli = is bought
In your sentence, both uses appear:
- disimpan → passive verb (prefix, no space)
- di rak tinggi di ruang tamu → two locative prepositional phrases (preposition, with space)
So:
- di + verb (joined) → passive marker
- di + noun (separated) → location preposition
In Malay, descriptive words (adjectives) normally come after the noun:
- rak tinggi = high/tall shelf
- rumah besar = big house
- baju merah = red shirt
So the pattern is:
- noun + adjective
Saying tinggi rak would be incorrect in standard Malay when you just mean “tall/high shelf”. The adjective often keeps the same form; you don’t need anything like -er or -est markers.
In di rak tinggi di ruang tamu, there are two separate location phrases:
- di rak tinggi = on the high shelf
- di ruang tamu = in the living room
So you get:
- Buku itu disimpan
di rak tinggi
di ruang tamu.
Repeating di makes it clear that you have two distinct places: shelf and living room.
You could say di rak tinggi ruang tamu, and it would be interpreted as one complex noun phrase:
- rak tinggi ruang tamu ≈ “the living-room high shelf”
This is possible, but it sounds more like naming a specific shelf (“the living room’s high shelf”) rather than clearly listing two separate locations. The version with two di is clearer and more typical for learners.
Malay does not mark tense the way English does. Disimpan by itself is tenseless; context gives the time reference.
Buku itu disimpan di rak tinggi di ruang tamu can mean:
- The book is kept on the high shelf in the living room.
(habitual / general practice) - The book is being kept / is stored on the high shelf in the living room.
(current state)
If the context is about where it usually goes, English “is kept” fits well. If the context is “Where is the book now?”, it can also mean it is (currently) kept / stored there.
To make tense/aspect more explicit, Malay usually adds time words:
- Buku itu telah disimpan… = the book has been / was kept… (past)
- Buku itu sedang disimpan… = the book is being kept… (ongoing action)
You can, but the meaning changes slightly.
Buku itu disimpan…
→ Refers to a specific book that both speaker and listener can identify (like the book).Buku disimpan…
→ More generic:- “Books are kept on the high shelf in the living room,” or
- “A book is kept…” (non-specific), depending on context.
Without itu/ini, Malay nouns often feel indefinite or general. With itu, it becomes a particular, known book.
Ruang tamu is a compound noun made of two words:
- ruang = space, area, room (in a general sense)
- tamu = guest
Together, ruang tamu literally means guest room/guest area, and in modern usage it corresponds to:
- living room / sitting room / lounge
It’s written as two words, but understood as a single fixed phrase: ruang tamu = living room.
Buku itu disimpan di rak tinggi di ruang tamu. is neutral and natural. It’s acceptable in:
- Everyday speech
- Writing (narratives, descriptions)
- Neutral/formal contexts (explanations, instructions)
In very casual speech, people might also say things like:
- Buku itu letak di rak tinggi di ruang tamu.
(using letak “to put/place” instead of disimpan)
But your original sentence is perfectly normal, polite, and widely usable.