Breakdown of Discipulus dicit se volumen suum in bibliotheca reliquisse.
Questions & Answers about Discipulus dicit se volumen suum in bibliotheca reliquisse.
Why is reliquisse an infinitive instead of a normal finite verb like reliquit?
Because after dicit (he says), Latin often uses indirect statement rather than a clause with that.
So instead of saying:
- The student says that he left his book...
Latin says, literally:
- The student says himself to have left his book...
That pattern is called the accusative-and-infinitive construction:
- se = the subject of the reported statement, in the accusative
- reliquisse = the infinitive verb of the reported statement
So Discipulus dicit se volumen suum in bibliotheca reliquisse is a standard indirect statement.
Why is it se and not is or eum?
Se is the reflexive accusative pronoun, and it refers back to the subject of the main verb, here discipulus.
So:
- Discipulus dicit se... reliquisse = The student says that he himself left...
If Latin used eum instead, that would normally suggest some other male person, not the student himself.
So se is used because the person doing the saying and the person who left the book are the same person.
Why is suum used? What does it refer to?
Suum is the reflexive possessive adjective, meaning his own, her own, or their own, depending on context.
Here it refers back to se, and therefore back to discipulus:
- volumen suum = his own book/scroll
This is different from eius, which would usually mean his/her referring to someone else.
So Latin is making it clear that the book belonged to the student, not to another person.
Why is se accusative?
In an indirect statement, the subject of the reported action goes into the accusative case.
In the reported idea:
- he left his book in the library
the word he becomes se in Latin because it is the subject of the infinitive reliquisse, and in this construction that subject must be accusative.
So even though se is logically the subject of reliquisse, grammatically it appears in the accusative.
What tense is reliquisse, and why is that tense used?
Reliquisse is the perfect active infinitive of relinquo.
It shows action that happened before the action of the main verb:
- dicit = he says now
- reliquisse = to have left / that he left earlier
So the meaning is:
- The student says that he left his book in the library
not:
- The student says that he is leaving
- The student says that he leaves in a general sense
The perfect infinitive marks the leaving as already completed.
How do I parse reliquisse?
Reliquisse comes from relinquo, relinquere, reliqui, relictum = leave behind.
Its form here is:
- perfect active infinitive
You can think of it as built from the perfect stem:
- reliqu-
- -isse
So:
- reliquisse = to have left
This is a very common form in indirect statement after verbs like dicit, putat, scit, audit, and so on.
Why is in bibliotheca ablative?
Because in with the ablative usually means in or inside a place.
So:
- in bibliotheca = in the library
By contrast, in with the accusative usually implies motion into something:
- in bibliothecam = into the library
Here the sentence is about where the book was left, not movement into the library, so the ablative is used.
What exactly does volumen mean?
Originally, volumen means a roll or scroll, from the idea of something rolled up. In many teaching contexts it is translated simply as book.
So:
- volumen suum can be understood as his book or his scroll, depending on context
If your course translates it as book, that is perfectly normal for learners.
Why is the word order like this? Could the words be arranged differently?
Yes, Latin word order is fairly flexible because the endings show the grammar.
This sentence is arranged as:
- Discipulus = subject
- dicit = main verb
- se ... reliquisse = indirect statement
- volumen suum = object inside that indirect statement
- in bibliotheca = place
But other orders are possible, for example:
- Discipulus se volumen suum in bibliotheca reliquisse dicit
- Se volumen suum in bibliotheca reliquisse discipulus dicit
These still mean essentially the same thing, though the emphasis may shift. The given order is clear and natural.
Could Latin leave out se here?
Normally, in this kind of sentence, se is needed because the indirect statement needs a subject.
So:
- dicit se reliquisse = he says that he left
If you removed se, the sentence would be incomplete or much less clear, because reliquisse still needs someone as its subject in the indirect statement.
Latin often omits subject pronouns with finite verbs, but this is different: se is not just an optional pronoun here. It is part of the accusative-and-infinitive structure.
Is suum agreeing with discipulus or with volumen?
Grammatically, suum agrees with volumen, because it is an adjective modifying it.
So it matches volumen in:
- gender: neuter
- number: singular
- case: accusative
That is why it is suum, not some other form.
However, in meaning, suum refers back to discipulus through se. So it agrees grammatically with volumen, but it points back logically to the student.
Can this sentence be translated literally, and if so, what would that look like?
Yes. A very literal translation would be:
- The student says himself to have left his book in the library.
That sounds unnatural in English, but it shows the Latin structure clearly:
- Discipulus = the student
- dicit = says
- se = himself
- volumen suum = his book
- in bibliotheca = in the library
- reliquisse = to have left
Natural English usually changes this to:
- The student says that he left his book in the library.
How do I know that se refers to the student and not to someone else?
Because se is reflexive: it normally points back to the subject of its own clause or governing statement.
Here the governing verb is dicit, whose subject is discipulus. So se naturally refers to discipulus.
That is one of the main jobs of se in Latin: to show that the person in the reported statement is the same as the main subject.
If Latin wanted to refer to another person, it would usually use a different pronoun, such as eum.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Discipulus dicit se volumen suum in bibliotheca reliquisse to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions