Breakdown of Pater autem Carthaginem navigare mavult, nam Carthagini fullones periti esse dicuntur.
Questions & Answers about Pater autem Carthaginem navigare mavult, nam Carthagini fullones periti esse dicuntur.
Why is autem not the first word in the sentence?
Because autem is usually postpositive in Latin: it tends to come after the first word, not before it.
So:
- Pater autem = Father, however... / But Father...
That word order is normal Latin.
What exactly does mavult mean?
Mavult means prefers or would rather.
It is the 3rd person singular present of the irregular verb malo, malle, malui.
So:
- navigare mavult = he prefers to sail
Latin often uses malo with an infinitive, just as English uses prefer with to + verb.
Why is navigare an infinitive?
Because it depends on mavult.
After verbs like want, prefer, be able, and similar verbs, Latin often uses an infinitive:
- mavult navigare = he prefers to sail
So navigare is not the main verb of the sentence; it completes the meaning of mavult.
Why is it Carthaginem navigare and not ad Carthaginem navigare?
With names of cities and towns, Latin often shows motion toward a place by using the accusative without a preposition.
So:
- Carthaginem = to Carthage
That is why Carthaginem navigare means to sail to Carthage.
A learner should notice the contrast here:
- Carthaginem = to Carthage
- Carthagini = in Carthage
What case is Carthagini?
Here Carthagini means in Carthage.
This is commonly explained as a locative form, used especially with names of cities and towns to express place where. In this word, it looks the same as the dative.
So the sentence contrasts two different ideas:
- Carthaginem = movement to Carthage
- Carthagini = location in Carthage
How does fullones periti esse dicuntur work?
This is a very common Latin construction with a passive verb of saying plus an infinitive.
Literally, it is:
- fullones = fullers
- periti esse = to be skilled
- dicuntur = are said
So:
- fullones periti esse dicuntur = fullers are said to be skilled
Latin often keeps the infinitive esse in this kind of reported statement.
Why is it periti and not peritos?
Because in this sentence fullones is the subject of dicuntur, so periti agrees with it in the nominative plural.
- fullones = nominative plural subject
- periti = nominative plural adjective agreeing with fullones
If the sentence were active, the construction would be different:
- fullones peritos esse dicunt = they say that fullers are skilled
Notice something slightly tricky: fullones has the same form in nominative plural and accusative plural, so the visible clue is really periti/peritos.
Why is esse included? Could Latin leave it out?
Latin often includes esse in indirect statement after verbs of saying, thinking, knowing, and similar verbs.
So:
- periti esse dicuntur = are said to be skilled
Sometimes Latin can omit forms of esse in other contexts, but here keeping esse is completely normal and clear.
What does periti mean exactly? Is something missing after it?
Periti means skilled, expert, or experienced.
Sometimes peritus can be followed by a word showing what someone is skilled in, but it does not have to be. Here the sense is simply that the fullers are skilled at their trade, and Latin leaves that understood from the context.
Why is the word order so different from English?
Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order because the endings show how the words function.
In this sentence, the order helps highlight ideas:
- Pater autem puts Father first, then adds however
- Carthaginem comes before navigare to make the destination clear early
- Carthagini is placed near the start of the second clause to stress in Carthage
- dicuntur comes at the end, which is very common in Latin
So the sentence may feel unusual in English order, but it is natural Latin.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Pater autem Carthaginem navigare mavult, nam Carthagini fullones periti esse dicuntur to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions