Breakdown of Cum pater domum rediit, filia ei epistulam ostendit.
Questions & Answers about Cum pater domum rediit, filia ei epistulam ostendit.
What does cum mean here, and why is the verb rediit in the indicative?
Here cum means when.
In Latin, cum can introduce different kinds of clauses:
- when
- since
- although
In this sentence, it introduces a simple time clause: When the father returned home, the daughter showed him a letter.
Because it is just stating a straightforward event in time, Latin uses cum with the indicative here, not the subjunctive.
So:
- cum pater domum rediit = when the father returned home
Why is it domum and not something like ad domum?
Latin often uses domum by itself to mean homeward or to home.
This is a special idiomatic use of an accusative of motion toward:
- domum = home
- Romam = to Rome
- rus / rurum have similar special patterns in some contexts
So:
- pater domum rediit = the father returned home
English needs to or just says returned home, but Latin does not need a preposition here.
What form is rediit?
Rediit is:
- 3rd person singular
- perfect active indicative
- from redeō, redīre, rediī/rediit = to go back, return
So rediit means:
- he returned
- or he has returned, depending on context
In this sentence, the natural translation is returned.
Why is pater the subject of the first clause and filia the subject of the second clause?
Because both nouns are in the nominative singular, which is the usual case for the subject.
- pater = father → nominative singular
- filia = daughter → nominative singular
So the sentence has two clauses:
- cum pater domum rediit = when the father returned home
- filia ei epistulam ostendit = the daughter showed him a letter
Latin often changes subjects from one clause to another without needing extra words like English sometimes does.
What case is ei, and what does it mean?
Ei is dative singular of the pronoun is, ea, id.
Here it means:
- to him
- or more naturally in English, just him
With the verb ostendere (to show), Latin often uses:
- the thing shown in the accusative
- the person shown to in the dative
So:
- epistulam = the letter (thing shown)
- ei = to him (person receiving the showing)
Thus:
- filia ei epistulam ostendit = the daughter showed him a letter
Why is epistulam in the accusative?
Because it is the direct object of ostendit.
The verb ostendere means to show. The thing being shown is put in the accusative.
So:
- epistula = letter (nominative)
- epistulam = letter as direct object (accusative)
In this sentence, the daughter is showing the letter, so Latin uses epistulam.
What form is ostendit, and how should it be translated?
Ostendit is:
- 3rd person singular
- perfect active indicative
- from ostendō, ostendere, ostendī, ostentum = to show
Here it means:
- she showed
Because the subject is filia, we translate it as she showed or the daughter showed.
Notice that ostendit can also be a present tense form in some contexts (he/she shows) for certain verbs, but here the sentence clearly uses it as a perfect: the action happened after the father came home.
Why are both verbs in the perfect tense?
Both actions are presented as completed past events:
- rediit = returned
- ostendit = showed
This is very common in narrative Latin. The perfect tense often tells the main sequence of events:
- the father returned home
- the daughter showed him a letter
English usually also uses the simple past here.
Why doesn’t Latin use words for the or a?
Classical Latin has no articles.
So a noun like pater can mean:
- the father
- a father
- sometimes just father, depending on context
Likewise:
- filia = the daughter or a daughter
- epistulam = a letter or the letter
The context tells you what is most natural. In this sentence, English usually says:
- When the father returned home, the daughter showed him a letter.
But in another context, the letter might also be possible.
Why is the word order different from normal English word order?
Latin word order is more flexible because the endings show each word’s role.
English depends heavily on word order:
- The daughter showed him a letter
Latin can move words around more freely:
- filia ei epistulam ostendit
- epistulam filia ei ostendit
- ei filia epistulam ostendit
All of these can mean basically the same thing, though the emphasis may shift.
In your sentence, the order is quite natural:
- filia first introduces the subject of the main clause
- ei comes early because it is a short pronoun
- epistulam comes before the verb
- ostendit finishes the clause, which is very common in Latin
Could ei refer to someone other than pater?
Grammatically, ei just means to him or to her depending on context, so by itself it could refer to some previously mentioned person.
But in this sentence, the natural reference is pater:
- When the father returned home, the daughter showed him a letter.
So learners should understand ei here as referring back to pater.
Is there anything special about the placement of the cum clause?
Yes. The cum clause comes first:
- Cum pater domum rediit, ...
Latin often puts a subordinate clause like this before the main clause to set the scene first. English does this too:
- When the father returned home, the daughter showed him a letter.
Latin could place the main clause first and the cum clause later, but the version you have is very natural and common.
How can I tell that filia is singular and not plural?
Because filia is nominative singular of the first-declension noun filia, filiae.
Compare:
- filia = daughter / the daughter
- filiae = daughters or sometimes of the daughter, depending on case and context
Here the verb ostendit is also singular, which confirms that the subject is one daughter:
- filia ... ostendit = the daughter showed
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Cum pater domum rediit, filia ei epistulam ostendit to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions