Breakdown of Pater dicit vinum bonum ex Hispania saepe Romam portari.
Questions & Answers about Pater dicit vinum bonum ex Hispania saepe Romam portari.
Why is portari an infinitive instead of a normal verb like portatur?
Because after dicit (“says”), Latin often uses indirect statement.
In English, we usually say Father says that good wine is often carried...
In Latin, instead of using that + a finite verb, you usually use:
- an accusative subject
- plus an infinitive
So:
- dicit = “he says”
- vinum bonum ... portari = “good wine ... to be carried / is carried”
This is a very common Latin construction called the accusative-and-infinitive construction.
Why is vinum bonum in the accusative?
Because in an indirect statement, the subject of the infinitive goes into the accusative.
Here, the thing being said is:
- vinum bonum ... portari = “good wine ... is carried”
Even though vinum bonum is the logical subject of portari, Latin puts it in the accusative because it is the subject of an infinitive in indirect statement.
So:
- vinum bonum = accusative singular
- it functions as the subject of portari
Why is portari passive?
Portari is the present passive infinitive of portare.
- portare = “to carry”
- portari = “to be carried”
That means the sentence is not saying that the wine carries something else. It is saying that the wine is carried / transported.
So the idea is:
- Father says [that] good wine is often transported to Rome from Spain.
What tense is portari, and how should I understand it?
Portari is a present infinitive, specifically a present passive infinitive.
In indirect statement, the present infinitive usually shows action happening at the same time as the main verb.
So:
- Pater dicit ... portari = “Father says ... is being carried / is carried”
In smoother English, this often becomes simply “Father says that good wine is often transported...”
Why is it bonum and not bonus?
Because bonum is an adjective agreeing with vinum.
- vinum is neuter singular accusative
- so the adjective must also be neuter singular accusative
- therefore: bonum
Agreement in Latin means adjectives match their nouns in:
- gender
- number
- case
So:
- vinum bonum = “good wine”
Why is there no word for that after dicit?
Because Latin usually does not need a separate word meaning that in this kind of sentence.
English says:
- Father says that good wine...
Latin usually says:
- Pater dicit vinum bonum... portari
The accusative + infinitive construction does the job that that-clause does in English.
Why is it Romam without a preposition?
Because names of cities often use the accusative without a preposition to show motion toward a place.
So:
- Romam = “to Rome”
This is a special and very common Latin idiom with towns and cities.
Compare:
- Romam = “to Rome”
- Romae = “at Rome / in Rome” (in another construction)
- Roma = “from Rome” (in another construction)
Why is it ex Hispania, but just Romam?
Because Latin treats these two ideas differently here:
- Romam shows motion toward a city, so no preposition is needed.
- ex Hispania means motion out of / from Spain, and with countries or larger regions Latin normally uses a preposition such as ex or ab.
So:
- Romam = “to Rome”
- ex Hispania = “from Spain”
Also, Hispania is in the ablative after ex.
What case is Hispania, and why?
It is ablative singular because it follows the preposition ex.
- ex = “out of, from”
- prepositions like ex take the ablative
So:
- ex Hispania = “from Spain”
What does saepe modify?
Saepe means often, and it modifies the verbal idea portari.
So the sense is:
- good wine is often carried
- not just “good wine” in some special way
Latin adverbs can often move around fairly freely, so saepe does not have to stand right next to the verb to modify it.
Is the word order important here?
Latin word order is more flexible than English word order, because the endings show the grammatical relationships.
So this sentence could be rearranged in various ways without changing the basic meaning, for example:
- Pater dicit vinum bonum ex Hispania saepe Romam portari.
- Pater dicit saepe vinum bonum ex Hispania Romam portari.
- Vinum bonum ex Hispania Romam saepe portari pater dicit.
The basic meaning stays the same, though different word orders can give different emphasis.
Why is there no word for the or a?
Because Latin has no articles.
So pater can mean:
- father
- the father
- a father
and vinum bonum can mean:
- good wine
- the good wine
- sometimes even a good wine, depending on context
You decide which English article to use from the context.
Could vinum bonum mean good wine in general, not one specific wine?
Yes. Very often, a phrase like vinum bonum can be understood generally as good wine.
Without articles, Latin does not force the distinction between:
- good wine
- the good wine
The context tells you whether it is general or specific.
Who is doing the carrying in this sentence?
The sentence does not say.
Because portari is passive, we are told what happens to the wine, not who does it.
So the meaning is simply:
- good wine is often carried / transported to Rome from Spain
If Latin wanted to say who was doing it, it could add an agent, for example with ab + ablative in an appropriate context.
Why is pater nominative?
Because pater is the subject of the main verb dicit.
So the sentence is built like this:
- Pater = subject of dicit
- dicit = main verb
- vinum bonum ex Hispania saepe Romam portari = the indirect statement, “that good wine is often carried...”
So there are really two layers:
- Father says
- good wine is often carried to Rome from Spain
Can I translate portari as to be transported instead of to be carried?
Yes. That is often the most natural English here.
- portare basically means to carry
- but in many contexts, especially with goods and trade, transport is a very good translation
So a natural translation is:
- Father says that good wine is often transported to Rome from Spain.
That is probably smoother English than a very literal carried.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Pater dicit vinum bonum ex Hispania saepe Romam portari to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions