Breakdown of Mater puellam monet ut candelam ante somnum extinguat.
Questions & Answers about Mater puellam monet ut candelam ante somnum extinguat.
Why is puellam in the accusative?
Because puellam is the direct object of monet.
In this sentence, mater is the one doing the action, and puellam is the person being advised or warned:
- mater = mother
- puellam = the girl
So Mater puellam monet means The mother advises/warns the girl.
This is a very common pattern with moneō: the person warned or advised goes in the accusative.
What does monet mean here: warns or advises?
It can mean either, depending on context.
The verb moneō, monēre often means:
- to remind
- to warn
- to advise
In this sentence, Mother tells/advises the girl to put out the candle before sleep is probably the most natural idea.
But warns the girl to put out the candle is also possible.
So the exact English wording may vary, even though the Latin structure stays the same.
Why is there an ut clause after monet?
Because Latin often uses ut + subjunctive after verbs of advising, urging, persuading, warning, or requesting to express that someone should do something.
So:
- monet ut ... extinguat = advises/warns her to extinguish ...
English often uses an infinitive here:
- The mother advises the girl to extinguish the candle
But Latin usually prefers a full clause:
- Mother advises the girl that she should extinguish the candle
That is why ut appears.
Why is extinguat in the subjunctive?
Because it is inside an ut clause expressing purpose or desired action after monet.
After verbs like moneō, Latin commonly uses:
- ut + subjunctive
So extinguat is not an indicative she extinguishes, but a subjunctive meaning something like:
- that she should extinguish
- to extinguish
In other words:
- Mater puellam monet ut candelam ante somnum extinguat
- The mother advises the girl to extinguish the candle before sleep
The subjunctive is required by the construction.
Why is extinguat present subjunctive instead of imperfect subjunctive?
Because the main verb monet is present, and Latin normally follows sequence of tenses.
Here the main verb is a primary tense:
- monet = advises / is advising
So the subordinate verb usually takes the present subjunctive:
- extinguat
If the main verb were in a past tense, you would often expect the imperfect subjunctive instead:
- Mater puellam monuit ut candelam ante somnum exstingueret
- The mother advised the girl to extinguish the candle before sleep
So extinguat fits the present-time main verb.
Why is candelam also in the accusative?
Because candelam is the direct object of extinguat.
The girl is being told to extinguish the candle, so candelam is the thing being extinguished.
That gives us two different accusatives in the sentence, but they belong to different verbs:
- puellam goes with monet
- candelam goes with extinguat
So the structure is:
- Mater = subject of monet
- puellam = object of monet
- candelam = object of extinguat
What does ante somnum mean exactly?
It means before sleep or more naturally in English, before going to sleep / before bed.
- ante = before
- somnum = sleep
Because ante takes the accusative, somnum is accusative.
Latin often uses expressions like this where English might prefer a slightly freer translation. So all of these can work depending on context:
- before sleep
- before going to sleep
- before bed
Why is somnum accusative?
Because ante is a preposition that takes the accusative when it means before in time or place.
So:
- ante + accusative
That is why we get:
- ante somnum = before sleep
This is just a normal prepositional phrase.
Who is supposed to extinguish the candle?
The girl is.
Even though puellam is not the grammatical subject of extinguat, the meaning of the sentence makes it clear that the girl is the one who is being told to do it.
So the logic is:
- Mother advises the girl
- that the girl should extinguish the candle
Latin often leaves the subject of the subordinate verb unstated when it is obvious from context.
Could Latin have used an infinitive instead of ut ... extinguat?
Normally, with moneō in this kind of meaning, Latin prefers ut + subjunctive rather than a simple infinitive.
English says:
- warns the girl to extinguish the candle
But Latin more naturally says:
- warns/advises the girl that she should extinguish the candle
So the finite clause with ut is idiomatic Latin here.
Is the word order important here?
Not in the same way as in English. Latin word order is flexible because the endings show the grammar.
Here:
- Mater = subject
- puellam = object of monet
- ut candelam ante somnum extinguat = content of the advice
This order is natural and clear, but Latin could rearrange parts for emphasis.
For example, candelam might be moved earlier or later without changing the core meaning. What matters most are the endings and the clause structure, not a fixed word order.
What is the dictionary form of extinguat?
The dictionary form is extinguō, exstinguere or sometimes spelled extinguō, extinguere depending on orthography.
Extinguat is:
- 3rd person singular
- present subjunctive
- active
So it means:
- that she may extinguish
- that she should extinguish
In this sentence, the subject is understood to be the girl.
Is mater nominative even though it does not have a special ending like -a becoming -am?
Yes. Mater is nominative singular.
This is a third-declension noun, so its forms are different from first-declension nouns like puella.
Its basic forms are:
- nominative singular: mater
- accusative singular: matrem
So in this sentence, mater is the subject: the mother.
A learner might expect something more like first-declension patterns, but mater follows a different declension.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Mater puellam monet ut candelam ante somnum extinguat to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions