Breakdown of Cum hospes in atrium intrat, puella osculum matri dat et blanda voce “Salve” dicit.
Questions & Answers about Cum hospes in atrium intrat, puella osculum matri dat et blanda voce “Salve” dicit.
Why does cum mean when here instead of with?
Because cum can do two different jobs:
- as a preposition with the ablative, it means with
- as a conjunction introducing a clause, it can mean when, since, or although
Here it is followed by a full clause, hospes in atrium intrat, so it is a conjunction. That is why it means when.
Why is the verb after cum written as intrat and not in the subjunctive?
This is a straightforward temporal clause: when the guest enters. In that kind of sentence, Latin can use cum + indicative.
So:
- cum ... intrat = when ... enters
Learners often meet cum with the subjunctive later on, especially in more literary or historical writing. But here the idea is simple and factual, so the indicative intrat is perfectly normal.
Why is it in atrium and not in atrio?
Because in changes meaning depending on the case:
- in + accusative = motion into somewhere
- in + ablative = location in or inside somewhere
Since the guest is entering into the atrium, Latin uses the accusative:
- in atrium = into the atrium
If the sentence meant the guest is in the atrium, it would use the ablative: in atrio.
What case is hospes, and what exactly is it doing in the sentence?
Hospes is nominative singular, the subject of intrat.
So in the clause Cum hospes in atrium intrat:
- hospes = the guest
- intrat = enters
It is a third-declension noun. Depending on context, hospes can mean guest, and it can refer to a man or a woman. In this sentence, it simply means the guest.
Why is matri dative instead of accusative?
Because do, dare means to give, and with verbs of giving Latin usually uses:
- the thing given in the accusative
- the person receiving it in the dative
So here:
- osculum = the thing given, so it is accusative
- matri = the person receiving it, so it is dative
That is why matri means to the mother.
Why does Latin say osculum dat? Does that literally mean gives a kiss?
Yes. It literally means gives a kiss, and that is a normal Latin way to express the idea.
So:
- osculum dat = she gives a kiss
- in natural English, that may simply be translated as she kisses
Latin could express kissing in other ways too, but osculum dare is a very common and idiomatic expression.
What case is blanda voce, and why is there no preposition?
Blanda voce is in the ablative singular.
It is an example of the ablative of manner (or means), showing how she speaks:
- blanda voce = in a gentle voice / with a gentle voice
Latin often omits cum with this kind of phrase when the noun has an adjective with it. So both of these would be possible in Latin:
- blanda voce
- cum blanda voce
Also notice agreement:
- blanda matches voce
- both are feminine, singular, ablative
Why is it Salve?
Salve is a standard Latin greeting meaning hello or more literally be well.
Grammatically, it is a singular imperative. It is used when speaking to one person.
So:
- Salve = said to one person
- Salvete = said to more than one person
In this sentence, the girl is greeting one person, so Salve is the correct form.
Why is there no separate Latin word for she before dicit?
Because Latin often leaves subject pronouns unstated when they are obvious from the verb form or the context.
The ending of dicit already tells you the verb is:
- third person singular = he/she/it says
Then the context tells you who that person is. Here the main subject is puella, so dicit naturally means the girl says.
Latin does have pronouns such as ea for she, but they are usually used only when needed for emphasis or clarity.
How do I know that puella, not hospes, is the one who says Salve?
Because hospes belongs to the subordinate clause introduced by cum:
- Cum hospes in atrium intrat = When the guest enters ...
After that clause ends, the main clause begins:
- puella osculum matri dat et blanda voce Salve dicit
In the main clause, puella is the nominative subject, and it naturally continues as the subject of both dat and dicit.
So the structure is:
- when the guest enters,
- the girl gives a kiss to her mother
- and the girl says Salve
Why is the word order different from English?
Because Latin uses case endings much more than word order to show what each word is doing.
For example:
- puella is nominative, so it is the subject
- osculum is accusative, so it is the direct object
- matri is dative, so it is the indirect object
- voce is ablative, so it shows manner
Since those endings already mark the roles, Latin has more freedom in word order than English.
This sentence uses word order in a natural Latin way:
- the time clause comes first: Cum hospes in atrium intrat
- then the main action: puella osculum matri dat
- then the manner and the spoken word before dicit: blanda voce Salve dicit
English is usually more rigid, but Latin can move words around for flow, emphasis, or style.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Cum hospes in atrium intrat, puella osculum matri dat et blanda voce “Salve” dicit to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions