Breakdown of Hoc consilium discipulis prodest, quia desidiam minuit et perseverantiam auget.
Questions & Answers about Hoc consilium discipulis prodest, quia desidiam minuit et perseverantiam auget.
Why is it hoc consilium and not hic consilium?
Because consilium is a neuter singular noun, and the demonstrative hic, haec, hoc has to agree with it in gender, number, and case.
- hoc = nominative singular neuter
- consilium = nominative singular neuter
So hoc consilium means this plan or this advice.
If the noun were masculine, you would expect hic instead.
What case is hoc consilium, and how do we know it is the subject?
Hoc consilium is in the nominative singular, which is the case normally used for the subject of a sentence.
We know it is the subject because:
- prodest is third person singular
- consilium is singular
- the meaning fits: this plan benefits the students
So hoc consilium is the thing doing the action of prodest.
Why is discipulis in the dative case?
Because prodesse regularly takes the dative of the person or thing benefited.
So:
- discipulis = to the students or for the students
- hoc consilium discipulis prodest = this plan is beneficial to the students
This is a very common Latin pattern:
- alicui prodesse = to benefit someone
A native English speaker often wants an accusative here, but Latin uses the dative instead.
What exactly is prodest?
Prodest is the third person singular present active indicative of prosum, prodesse, profui.
It means:
- is useful
- is beneficial
- benefits
It is an irregular compound built from pro- plus sum / esse.
So:
- prodest = it benefits or it is of use
That is why the construction is a little different from a more ordinary verb.
Why is prodest singular?
Because its subject, hoc consilium, is singular.
Latin verbs agree with their subjects in person and number. Since consilium is one plan, the verb must also be singular:
- consilium ... prodest = the plan benefits
- if it were plural, you would expect prosunt
What does quia do in this sentence?
Quia means because and introduces a clause giving the reason.
So the structure is:
- main clause: Hoc consilium discipulis prodest
- reason clause: quia desidiam minuit et perseverantiam auget
In other words: the plan benefits the students because it reduces laziness and increases perseverance.
Why are desidiam and perseverantiam in the accusative?
They are in the accusative because they are the direct objects of the verbs:
- desidiam minuit = it reduces laziness
- perseverantiam auget = it increases perseverance
Both minuere and augere are transitive verbs, so they take direct objects in the accusative.
What is the subject of minuit and auget?
The subject is still hoc consilium, even though Latin does not repeat it.
So the sentence is understood as:
- hoc consilium ... minuit
- hoc consilium ... auget
Latin often leaves out a repeated subject when it is already clear from the context. English usually repeats it, but Latin does not need to.
What tense are minuit and auget?
They are both present active indicative, third person singular.
So they mean:
- minuit = it reduces
- auget = it increases
The present tense here states a general truth or a present effect: this plan benefits students because it reduces one thing and increases another.
Why is there no separate word for it before minuit and auget?
Because Latin does not normally need an expressed subject pronoun when the verb ending already shows the person and number.
- minuit already means he/she/it reduces
- auget already means he/she/it increases
Since hoc consilium has already been named, Latin simply continues with the verbs.
What does consilium mean here: plan, advice, or counsel?
Consilium can mean several related things, including:
- plan
- strategy
- advice
- policy
- decision
In this sentence, the best English choice depends on context. If the sentence is about a method or approach used in teaching, plan or strategy is probably the most natural. If it is about guidance given to students, advice could also fit.
So a learner should not assume that one Latin noun always matches one exact English word.
Why is the word order different from normal English word order?
Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order because Latin uses case endings to show grammatical function.
English relies heavily on position:
- subject + verb + object
Latin can move words around more freely because forms such as discipulis, desidiam, and perseverantiam already show what they are doing in the sentence.
This order:
- Hoc consilium discipulis prodest, quia desidiam minuit et perseverantiam auget
is perfectly natural. A different order could also be grammatical, though it might change emphasis.
Are desidiam and perseverantiam abstract nouns, and does that affect how they are used?
Yes. Both are abstract nouns:
- desidia = laziness, idleness
- perseverantia = perseverance, persistence
In Latin, abstract nouns are often used in the singular when speaking generally, just as in English:
- laziness
- perseverance
So the sentence is not talking about one single act of laziness and one single act of perseverance, but about those qualities in general.
Are any of these words related to English words?
Yes, several are easy cognates:
- consilium is related in meaning to English counsel
- discipulis comes from discipulus, related to disciple
- desidia is related to desidious only very indirectly, but not a common transparent cognate for most learners
- perseverantia is clearly related to perseverance
- auget comes from augere, related to augment
Noticing cognates can help vocabulary, but it is still important to learn each Latin word in its own usage.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Hoc consilium discipulis prodest, quia desidiam minuit et perseverantiam auget to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions