Breakdown of Discipulae in bibliotheca tacent, quia magistra earum legit.
Questions & Answers about Discipulae in bibliotheca tacent, quia magistra earum legit.
Why does discipulae mean more than one person here?
Because discipulae is being used as a nominative plural subject here: the female students or the schoolgirls.
The form discipulae can be ambiguous in isolation, because it can also be genitive singular or dative singular. But the verb tacent is plural, so that tells you discipulae must be the plural subject.
Why is the verb tacent and not tacet?
Latin verbs change their endings to match the subject.
- tacet = she/he/it is silent
- tacent = they are silent
Since discipulae is plural, the verb must also be plural: tacent.
Why is it in bibliotheca and not in bibliothecam?
Because in takes different cases depending on meaning:
- in + ablative = in/on/at a place, with no movement
- in + accusative = into a place, showing motion toward it
So:
- in bibliotheca = in the library
- in bibliothecam = into the library
Here the students are already there, so Latin uses the ablative: bibliotheca.
What does quia do in this sentence?
Quia means because. It introduces a clause that gives the reason for what happens in the main clause.
So the structure is:
- Discipulae in bibliotheca tacent = main statement
- quia magistra earum legit = reason
In other words: they are silent because their teacher is reading.
How do we know magistra is the subject of legit?
Magistra is in the nominative singular, which is the normal case for the subject of a clause. The verb legit is also singular, so they fit together:
- magistra = the teacher
- legit = reads
So magistra legit means the teacher reads.
What does earum mean, and what case is it?
Earum means of them or their. It is genitive plural feminine.
It refers back to discipulae, so it means their in the sense the girls' or the female students'.
In magistra earum:
- magistra = teacher
- earum = of them / their
So literally it is the teacher of them, which English naturally says as their teacher.
Why does Latin use earum instead of sua?
Because suus, sua, suum is a reflexive possessive. It normally refers back to the subject of its own clause.
In the clause quia magistra earum legit, the subject is magistra. So if Latin said magistra sua, it would mean something like her own teacher—that is, the teacher belonging to the teacher, which is not the intended meaning.
But the possessor here is discipulae, the subject of the main clause, not the subject of the quia clause. So Latin uses earum, not sua.
Could legit mean read as well as reads?
Yes. In ordinary spelling, legit can be either:
- present: reads
- perfect: read / has read
Usually context tells you which one is meant. Here reads makes the best sense, because it explains why the students are silent at the same time.
If vowel length is marked, the perfect form is written lēgit, which helps distinguish it.
Is the word order important here?
Latin word order is fairly flexible, because the endings show how words function.
This sentence uses a very natural order, but other arrangements are possible, for example:
- In bibliotheca discipulae tacent
- Quia earum magistra legit, discipulae in bibliotheca tacent
The meaning stays basically the same, though the emphasis can change. Latin often likes to put the verb near the end, as in tacent and legit here.
Why is there no separate word for the?
Because Latin has no definite article and no indefinite article. It does not have exact equivalents of the or a/an.
So:
- discipulae can mean students, the students, or sometimes some students
- magistra can mean teacher, the teacher, or a teacher
English has to choose an article when translating, but Latin does not. Context tells you what is most natural.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Discipulae in bibliotheca tacent, quia magistra earum legit to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions