Breakdown of Avia saepe memorat se, cum iuvenis esset, has historias legere solitam esse; ego autem recordor me illam fabulam iam audivisse.
Questions & Answers about Avia saepe memorat se, cum iuvenis esset, has historias legere solitam esse; ego autem recordor me illam fabulam iam audivisse.
Why are se and me in the accusative instead of nominative ea or ego?
Because both clauses use indirect statement.
In Latin, the subject of an indirect statement is normally put in the accusative, and the verb goes into an infinitive.
So:
- se ... solitam esse = that she ... was accustomed
- me ... audivisse = that I ... had heard
Also, se is reflexive: it refers back to the subject of the main clause, avia. So avia memorat se... means Grandmother recalls that she..., where she means the grandmother herself.
Why do memorat and recordor take an infinitive construction here?
Because Latin often expresses that-clauses after verbs of saying, thinking, knowing, perceiving, and remembering by using the accusative-and-infinitive construction instead of a separate word meaning that.
So instead of something like:
- Grandmother recalls that she used to read...
- I remember that I had already heard...
Latin says:
- avia memorat se ... legere solitam esse
- ego recordor me ... audivisse
This is one of the most important Latin sentence patterns to get comfortable with.
What kind of clause is cum iuvenis esset?
It is a cum-clause giving the circumstances in the past: when she was young.
Here cum means something like when, and esset is the imperfect subjunctive of sum.
So the clause gives background information:
- cum iuvenis esset = when she was young
Latin very often uses cum + subjunctive for this kind of past background circumstance.
Why is it esset and not erat?
Because after this kind of cum, Latin normally uses the subjunctive, not the indicative.
So:
- erat would simply be she was
- esset is she were / was in the subjunctive, used here after cum
The imperfect tense also fits the background setting in past time: it describes her state during that earlier period of life.
Why is it iuvenis? What case is that?
Iuvenis is nominative singular here.
It is being used with esset as a predicate noun/adjective: with forms of to be, Latin normally puts the predicate in the nominative.
So the idea is:
- she was young
- not she was a young person in the accusative
A second point: iuvenis has the same form for masculine and feminine in the nominative singular, so it can describe a grandmother without any problem.
What exactly does solitam esse mean?
Solitam esse is from soleo, solere, solitus sum, which means to be accustomed or to be in the habit of.
So:
- legere solitam esse = to have been accustomed to read
- more naturally in English: to have used to read or simply to have used to read / to have been in the habit of reading
A very important detail: although solitam looks like a participle, soleo is one of those verbs whose perfect system is built with solitus sum but has an active meaning.
So solitam esse does not mean to have been accustomed by someone. It means to have been accustomed / to have had the habit.
Why is it solitam and not solitus or solitum?
Because solitam agrees with se, the subject of the indirect statement.
Here se refers to avia, so it is:
- feminine
- singular
- accusative
Therefore the agreeing form is:
- solitam
If the subject were masculine, you would expect solitum in the accusative singular masculine.
Why do we get legere solitam esse instead of just legisse?
Because the sentence is talking about a habit, not a single completed act of reading.
- legisse would mean to have read
- legere solitam esse means to have been accustomed to read / to have used to read
That is a very different idea.
Also, the infinitive legere stays in the present because it depends on solitam esse: it tells us what she used to do. The past reference is mainly carried by solitam esse, which places that habit before the present memorat.
Why is the second half me illam fabulam iam audivisse?
This is another indirect statement.
- me = the subject of the indirect statement
- illam fabulam = the object of audivisse
- audivisse = perfect infinitive, to have heard
The perfect infinitive is used because the hearing happened before the remembering:
- recordor = I remember now
- audivisse = that I had heard earlier
So the time relationship is important: the hearing is already completed by the time the speaker remembers it.
What does iam add in iam audivisse?
Iam means already.
It emphasizes that, by the time being referred to, the speaker had already heard that story.
So me illam fabulam iam audivisse is stronger than just me illam fabulam audivisse. It adds the sense of prior completion:
- I remember that I had already heard that story
Is recordor a normal active verb?
No. Recordor is a deponent verb.
That means it has passive-looking forms but an active meaning.
So:
- recordor looks passive in form
- but it means I remember, not I am remembered
This is why a learner has to memorize recordor as a deponent verb and translate it actively.
What does autem mean, and why is it placed where it is?
Autem means something like however, but, or on the other hand.
Latin often puts autem in second position in its clause, not necessarily at the very beginning as English would.
So:
- ego autem recordor... = I, however, remember...
That word order is very normal in Latin.
What case are has historias and illam fabulam, and why?
Both are accusative, because they are the direct objects of the infinitives:
- has historias goes with legere
- illam fabulam goes with audivisse
Their forms show agreement:
- has historias = feminine accusative plural, these stories
- illam fabulam = feminine accusative singular, that story
So the demonstratives and nouns match in case, number, and gender, just as they should.
What does saepe modify here?
Saepe most naturally modifies memorat.
So the sense is:
- Grandmother often recalls...
not:
- Grandmother recalls that she often used to read...
If Latin wanted to stress that the reading itself was frequent, it would usually place saepe more clearly with that part of the sentence. Here its position near memorat strongly suggests that it belongs to the main verb.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Avia saepe memorat se, cum iuvenis esset, has historias legere solitam esse; ego autem recordor me illam fabulam iam audivisse to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions