Breakdown of Magistra dicit talem disciplinam utilem esse, quoniam sine ordine nemo bene discere potest.
Questions & Answers about Magistra dicit talem disciplinam utilem esse, quoniam sine ordine nemo bene discere potest.
Because after a verb like dicit (says), Latin often uses an indirect statement instead of a clause with that.
In English, we say:
The teacher says that this kind of training is useful.
In Latin, that becomes:
Magistra dicit talem disciplinam utilem esse.
In this construction, the thing being said becomes the subject of the infinitive and goes into the accusative. So disciplinam is accusative because it is the subject of esse in the indirect statement.
It is accusative because it agrees with disciplinam, which is accusative.
Here utilem is a predicate adjective with esse. It describes disciplinam, so it must match it in:
- gender: feminine
- number: singular
- case: accusative
So:
- disciplina = nominative
- disciplinam = accusative
- utilis = nominative feminine singular
- utilem = accusative feminine singular
Because the sentence uses an indirect statement, both the noun and the adjective appear in the accusative: talem disciplinam utilem esse.