Breakdown of Medica collum pueri tangit et rogat utrum etiam umerus doleat.
Questions & Answers about Medica collum pueri tangit et rogat utrum etiam umerus doleat.
Why is medica used here instead of medicus?
Medica is the feminine form, so it means female doctor.
Medicus would mean male doctor.
In this sentence, medica is the subject: the female doctor is the one doing the actions tangit and rogat.
Why is collum in that form?
Collum is accusative singular, because it is the direct object of tangit (touches).
- nominative: collum = the neck as subject
- accusative: collum = the neck as object
Since the doctor touches the neck, Latin puts collum in the accusative.
Why is pueri used instead of puerum?
Here pueri is genitive singular, meaning of the boy or the boy’s.
So:
- collum pueri = the boy’s neck
It is not the object of the verb. The object is collum.
The word pueri just tells us whose neck it is.
How do we know pueri is genitive singular and not nominative plural?
Formally, pueri can mean either:
- genitive singular = of the boy
- nominative plural = boys
But the context makes it clear here:
- collum pueri naturally means the boy’s neck
- collum pueri cannot sensibly mean the neck boys
So this is a good example of how Latin sometimes relies on context when one form can have more than one grammatical meaning.
Why is tangit used here?
Tangit is the 3rd person singular present active indicative of tangere (to touch).
It means she touches.
It is 3rd singular because the subject is one person: medica.
Why doesn’t Latin repeat the subject before rogat?
Because Latin often leaves out a pronoun or repeated noun when the subject is already clear.
In Medica collum pueri tangit et rogat..., the same subject continues naturally:
- medica touches
- and (medica) asks
English often works the same way: The doctor touches the boy’s neck and asks...
What does utrum do in this sentence?
Utrum introduces an indirect yes/no question.
After a verb like rogat (asks), Latin often uses utrum to mean something like:
- whether
- if
So rogat utrum etiam umerus doleat means she asks whether the shoulder also hurts.
Why is it doleat and not dolet?
Because this is an indirect question, and Latin normally uses the subjunctive in indirect questions.
So:
- direct question: Etiamne umerus dolet? = Does the shoulder also hurt?
- indirect question: rogat utrum etiam umerus doleat = she asks whether the shoulder also hurts
That is why doleat is present subjunctive, not indicative.
Why is umerus nominative, not accusative?
Because umerus is the subject of doleat.
In the clause utrum etiam umerus doleat, the shoulder is the thing that hurts. So umerus must be nominative singular.
If it were accusative umerum, it would be a direct object, but dolere here works like to hurt / to be painful, with the body part as the subject.
What exactly does etiam mean here, and why is it placed there?
Etiam means also, too, or even.
Here it adds the idea that the doctor is asking about another body part as well:
- utrum etiam umerus doleat = whether the shoulder also hurts
Its position before umerus gives it a natural focus on the shoulder too. Latin word order is flexible, but this placement is very normal.
Is the word order important in this sentence?
Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order, because the endings show the grammar.
So the sentence could be rearranged in various ways without changing the basic meaning. For example, Latin could move pueri, etiam, or utrum for emphasis.
Still, the given order is natural and easy to follow:
- Medica = subject first
- collum pueri = object phrase
- tangit = verb
- et rogat = next action
- utrum etiam umerus doleat = indirect question
So the order is not the only possible one, but it is a very reasonable one.
Could utrum be omitted?
Sometimes Latin can introduce an indirect yes/no question without utrum, especially in some authors. But utrum is very common and very clear.
So:
- rogat utrum etiam umerus doleat
- and sometimes simply rogat etiam umerus doleat
The version with utrum is easier for learners, because it clearly signals whether / if.
What tense is doleat, and why is it present?
Doleat is present subjunctive.
It is present because the doctor is asking about something happening at the same time as the asking: whether the shoulder is hurting now.
So the sequence is:
- rogat = she asks (present)
- doleat = is hurting / may be hurting in the indirect question at the same time
This is normal Latin sequence of tenses with a primary tense like rogat.
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Medica collum pueri tangit et rogat utrum etiam umerus doleat to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions