tomodati ga kireina utagoe de utaikiru to, ookina hakusyu ga okotta.

Questions & Answers about tomodati ga kireina utagoe de utaikiru to, ookina hakusyu ga okotta.

Why is 友達 marked with が instead of は?

が marks 友達 as the subject of 歌い切る: the friend is the one who finishes singing.

Using は would make 友達 the topic instead, which would slightly change the feel:

  • 友達が = focusing on the friend as the subject
  • 友達は = as for my/the friend...

In this sentence, が works well because the sentence is narrating an event: the friend sang, and then applause happened.

Why is it きれいな歌声 and not きれいい歌声 or きれいの歌声?

きれい is a な-adjective, not an い-adjective, even though it ends in -い.

So:

  • before a noun: きれいな歌声
  • at the end of a sentence: 歌声がきれいだ

That is why you need な before 歌声.

What exactly does 歌声 mean here?

歌声 means singing voice or the sound of someone singing.

It is different from:

  • 声 = voice in general
  • 歌 = a song
  • 歌声 = the voice as it is heard in singing

So きれいな歌声 is not just a beautiful voice in a general sense, but specifically a beautiful singing voice.

What is the role of で in きれいな歌声で?

Here, で shows the means or manner.

So きれいな歌声で歌い切る means something like:

  • to sing all the way through with a beautiful singing voice
  • to finish singing in a beautiful voice

This is not the location-use of で. It is closer to with / by means of / in in English.

What does 歌い切る mean? Why not just 歌う?

歌い切る is a compound verb:

  • 歌う = to sing
  • 切る = to cut, but in compound verbs it often means to do something completely, all the way through, or to the end

So 歌い切る means:

  • to sing to the end
  • to finish singing completely
  • to get through the song

Using 歌う would just mean to sing.
Using 歌い切る adds a sense of completion.

Why is it 歌い切ると instead of 歌い切ったと if the whole sentence is in the past?

Before と in this kind of sentence, Japanese often uses the plain non-past form, even when talking about a past event.

So:

  • 歌い切ると、大きな拍手が起った。

means:

  • When/As soon as the friend finished singing, big applause broke out.

This pattern is very common in Japanese narration:

  • ドアを開けると、猫がいた。 = When I opened the door, there was a cat.

The past time is shown by the main verb 起った, not by making 歌い切る past.

What does と mean here? Is it just and?

No. Here と does not mean and.

It means something like:

  • when
  • as soon as
  • once

It often gives the feeling that the second event happens naturally, immediately, or as a result of the first one.

So:

  • 歌い切ると、大きな拍手が起った。 = When/As soon as the friend finished singing, there was a big round of applause.

This と is different from the quotation particle と and different from the and particle used to connect nouns.

Could と be replaced with たら or とき?

Yes, but the nuance would change.

  • 歌い切ると
    = when/as soon as; sounds like a natural sequence of events

  • 歌い切ったら
    = when/after finishing; a little more neutral and flexible

  • 歌い切ったとき
    = at the time when the friend finished singing; focuses more on the time point itself

In this sentence, と is good because it strongly suggests: the friend finished singing, and immediately applause broke out.

Why is there another が in 大きな拍手が起った?

Because 拍手 is the subject of the second verb, 起った.

So the sentence has two clauses:

  1. 友達が ... 歌い切る

    • subject: 友達
  2. 大きな拍手が起った

    • subject: 大きな拍手

This is completely normal in Japanese.
Each clause can have its own subject.

Why is it 大きな拍手? Does that literally mean big applause?

Yes, literally it is big applause, but in natural English it means:

  • loud applause
  • great applause
  • a big round of applause

Japanese often uses 大きい / 大きな with things like sounds, reactions, or effects in a way that English may translate less literally.

So 大きな拍手 is a very natural Japanese expression.

Why does the sentence use 起った for applause?

Japanese often uses 起こる for events that occur, happen, or break out.

So 拍手が起こる means:

  • applause breaks out
  • applause arises
  • there is applause

It sounds natural in Japanese, even if English would not normally say applause occurred in everyday speech.

A very natural translation would be:

  • A big round of applause broke out.
Is 起った normal spelling? I expected 起こった.

Yes, 起こった is the more common modern spelling.

The spelling 起った is a more abbreviated kanji-heavy way of writing the same word.
You may see it in literature, older texts, or stylistic writing, but for learners, 起こった is usually the form to remember first.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“How do verb conjugations work in Japanese?”
Japanese verbs conjugate based on tense, politeness, and mood. For example, the polite present form adds ‑ます to the verb stem, while the past tense uses ‑ました. Unlike English, Japanese verbs don't change based on the subject — the same form works for "I", "you", and "they".

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Japanese

Master Japanese — from tomodati ga kireina utagoe de utaikiru to, ookina hakusyu ga okotta to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions