Breakdown of kinoko ga haitta tenpura ha karukute, sohu mo okawarisite imasita.
Questions & Answers about kinoko ga haitta tenpura ha karukute, sohu mo okawarisite imasita.
Why is 入った in the past form before 天ぷら?
In Japanese, a verb in plain form can directly modify a noun. Here, 入った 天ぷら means tempura that had mushrooms in it or tempura with mushrooms inside.
The past form 入った does not necessarily mean the whole sentence is “in the past” in the English sense. In a noun-modifying clause, it often describes a completed state:
- きのこが入った天ぷら = tempura that contains mushrooms / tempura with mushrooms in it
It is similar to how English might say the tempura that had mushrooms in it, even if the main point is simply describing what kind of tempura it was.
Why is the particle が used in きのこが入った instead of を?
Because 入る is an intransitive verb.
- 入る = to enter, to be contained, to go in
- 入れる = to put something in
So:
- きのこが入った = mushrooms went in / mushrooms were inside
- きのこを入れた = someone put mushrooms in
In this sentence, the focus is on the tempura having mushrooms in it, not on who added them, so が is natural.
What exactly is きのこが入った天ぷら? Is it just mushroom tempura?
Yes, in natural English it could often be translated simply as mushroom tempura or tempura with mushrooms in it.
But the Japanese expression is a little more descriptive:
- きのこ = mushrooms
- が入った = that had mushrooms in it
- 天ぷら = tempura
So literally it is something like:
- the tempura that had mushrooms in it
This pattern is very common in Japanese:
- チーズが入ったパン = bread with cheese in it
- あんこが入ったもち = mochi with red bean paste inside
Why does 天ぷら have は after it?
は marks 天ぷら as the topic of the sentence.
So the sentence is talking about as for the tempura with mushrooms in it...
That topic is then followed by comments about it:
- 軽くて = it was light
- 祖父もおかわりしていました = Grandpa also had another helping
So は is not marking the direct subject in the same way English does. It sets up the thing being discussed.
What does 軽くて mean here? Does it literally mean the tempura was physically light in weight?
Not usually. With food, 軽い often means:
- light
- not heavy
- not greasy
- easy to eat
So 軽くて here probably means the tempura felt light rather than oily or overly filling.
The -て form connects this idea to the next clause:
- 軽くて、祖父もおかわりしていました。
- It was light, and Grandpa also had another helping.
Depending on context, it can feel like either simple connection (and) or a reason-like connection (because it was light...).
Why is 軽い changed to 軽くて?
Because 軽い is an i-adjective, and its -て form is 軽くて.
This form is used to connect clauses:
- 軽い = light
- 軽くて = being light / and it was light
- It was light, and ...
- Because it was light, ...
Other examples:
- 安くておいしい = cheap and delicious
- 大きくてきれい = big and beautiful
What does も mean in 祖父も?
も means also or too.
So 祖父も means:
- Grandpa too
- Grandpa also
This suggests that someone else may also have had another helping, or that Grandpa joined in as well.
Why is it 祖父 and not おじいさん?
祖父 is the more neutral word used for my grandfather / one’s grandfather when talking about him to other people.
- 祖父(そふ) = my grandfather / our grandfather
- おじいさん = grandfather / old man, often used when referring to someone else’s grandfather or when addressing a grandfather more directly
So if the speaker is talking about their own grandfather, 祖父 is the natural choice.
What does おかわりしていました mean exactly?
おかわり means another helping, a second serving, or seconds.
It often combines with する:
- おかわりする = to have another helping / to get seconds
So:
- 祖父もおかわりしていました = Grandpa was also having another helping / Grandpa also had seconds
In natural English, Grandpa also went back for seconds would fit well.
Why is there no particle between おかわり and していました?
Why is it していました instead of just した?
していました is the past polite form of している, which can show an ongoing action or a situation in progress.
So:
- おかわりした = had another helping
- おかわりしていました = was having another helping / was going back for seconds
In many contexts, -ていました gives a softer, more descriptive feel, as if the speaker is recalling what was happening at that time.
Also, いました makes the sentence polite.
Is the sentence mixing plain and polite forms?
A little, yes—but that is normal.
Parts like:
- 入った
- 軽くて
are plain forms because they are inside a modifier or a clause-linking form.
The sentence ends with:
- していました
which is polite.
This is very common in Japanese. The politeness of the sentence is usually determined mainly by the final verb.
Could きのこの天ぷら be used instead of きのこが入った天ぷら?
Sometimes yes, but the nuance is different.
- きのこの天ぷら usually means mushroom tempura
- きのこが入った天ぷら means tempura that had mushrooms in it
The second one sounds more specific and descriptive, as if mushrooms were part of the filling or contents of the tempura dish. It emphasizes that mushrooms were included inside it.
So both can be translated similarly in some contexts, but they are not always exactly the same in nuance.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from kinoko ga haitta tenpura ha karukute, sohu mo okawarisite imasita to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions