Breakdown of kinoko ga haitta pura ha karukute, sohu mo okawarisite imasita.
Questions & Answers about kinoko ga haitta pura ha karukute, sohu mo okawarisite imasita.
Why is が used in きのこが入った天ぷら?
Here, きのこが入った is a clause modifying 天ぷら.
- 入る means to enter / to be included / to be in
- In that clause, きのこ is the thing that entered / is included
- So きのこ is the subject of 入った, which is why it takes が
So:
- きのこが入った天ぷら = tempura that had mushrooms in it / tempura containing mushrooms
A learner might expect を, but 入る is an intransitive verb, so it does not take a direct object with を in this use.
How does 入った work before 天ぷら?
This is a relative clause: a clause placed before a noun to describe it.
So:
- きのこが入った = that mushrooms were included in
- 天ぷら = tempura
Together:
- きのこが入った天ぷら = the tempura that had mushrooms in it
Japanese does this very often. Instead of using a word like that or which, Japanese simply puts the describing clause directly before the noun.
Examples of the same pattern:
- 昨日買った本 = the book I bought yesterday
- 父が作った料理 = the dish my father made
Does 入った mean the tempura was in the past? Why not 入っている?
Not necessarily. In a relative clause, the past form often describes a completed action that results in the noun’s current state.
So きのこが入った天ぷら does not have to mean tempura that used to have mushrooms. It naturally means tempura with mushrooms in it.
Why 入った works well:
- it presents the mushrooms as something that were put in / came to be included
Why 入っている might also be possible:
- きのこが入っている天ぷら would emphasize the state of containing mushrooms
The difference is subtle here:
- 入った = slightly more compact, often very natural in descriptions
- 入っている = slightly more explicit about the current state
Why is は after 天ぷら?
The whole phrase きのこが入った天ぷら is the topic of the sentence, so は comes after the entire noun phrase.
- きのこが入った天ぷらは = as for the tempura with mushrooms in it, ...
This is very common in Japanese:
- build the noun phrase
- attach は to make it the topic
So は is not marking just 天ぷら by itself in a simple way; it marks the whole phrase:
- きのこが入った天ぷら
- は
What does 軽くて mean here, and why is it in the -て form?
軽くて is the -て form of the い-adjective 軽い.
- 軽い = light
- 軽くて = light, and...
The -て form links this description to the next part of the sentence.
So the structure is:
- 天ぷらは軽くて、祖父もおかわりしていました。
- The tempura was light, and Grandpa was also having seconds.
In food contexts, 軽い often means:
- not heavy
- not greasy
- easy to eat
So it is not necessarily about physical weight. It often describes a pleasant, not-too-rich texture or feeling.
Why does it say 祖父 instead of おじいさん?
祖父 is the speaker’s own grandfather in a neutral or somewhat formal way.
Japanese often distinguishes between:
- words used for your own family members when talking about them
- words used for someone else’s family members or when addressing them directly
So:
- 祖父 = my grandfather / our grandfather
- おじいさん = grandfather / old man, often used for someone else’s grandfather or as a more outward-facing term
- おじいちゃん = grandpa, more familiar/casual
In narration like this, 祖父 is very natural if the speaker is talking about their own grandfather.
What does も mean in 祖父も?
What does おかわりしていました mean grammatically?
おかわり means another helping / a refill / seconds.
It combines with する:
- おかわりする = to have another helping / to ask for seconds
Then it becomes:
- おかわりしていました
This is していました, the past form of しています, built from する.
So grammatically:
- おかわりする → dictionary form
- おかわりしている → is having seconds / is in the state of getting another helping
- おかわりしていた / していました → was having seconds / was getting another helping
The お- in おかわり is part of the fixed word here. It does not necessarily make the sentence especially polite toward Grandpa; おかわり is simply the normal word.
Why is it していました instead of just しました?
していました gives a sense of an ongoing action or scene in the past, or it describes what was happening at that time.
So:
- おかわりしました = had another helping
- おかわりしていました = was having another helping / was getting seconds
In storytelling, 〜ていました often paints the scene more naturally, like describing what someone was doing.
Here it can suggest:
- Grandpa was in the middle of getting/eating another serving
- or, more loosely, Grandpa went back for seconds as part of the situation being described
So していました feels a little more descriptive and scene-setting than the simpler しました.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from kinoko ga haitta pura ha karukute, sohu mo okawarisite imasita to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions