Breakdown of kutsu ga doro de kitanai node, genkan no soto de nugimashita.
Questions & Answers about kutsu ga doro de kitanai node, genkan no soto de nugimashita.
In 靴が泥で汚い, 靴 is the subject of the description dirty with mud, so が is natural.
- が = marks what has the property
- は = would make shoes the topic, as in As for the shoes, they're dirty with mud
- を would mark the object of 脱ぐ in the second clause, not the subject of 汚い
So in the first clause, 靴が is correct.
Here, で is not marking the place where something happens. It shows the thing causing or making the state: dirty with mud.
So 泥で汚い means something like:
- dirty because of mud
- muddy / dirty with mud
This use of で also appears in sentences like:
- 汗でぬれた = got wet with sweat
- ほこりで汚れた = got dirty with dust
In Japanese, subordinate clauses often use the plain form even when the main sentence is polite.
So this pattern is very common:
- 汚いので、ぬぎました
- plain form + ので
- polite form in the main clause
汚いですので is possible in some formal situations, but it sounds stiffer and is much less common in everyday speech.
