Breakdown of naruhodo, kono madori nara hutari de sunde mo amari semaku nasasou da.
Questions & Answers about naruhodo, kono madori nara hutari de sunde mo amari semaku nasasou da.
What does なるほど mean at the beginning?
なるほど is a reaction word meaning something like I see, I get it, or that makes sense.
It often appears when the speaker has just understood something or is evaluating new information. In this sentence, it sounds like the speaker is looking at the floor plan and thinking:
Ah, I see. In that case...
It does not add core grammar to the sentence; it mainly shows the speaker’s reaction.
What does 間取り mean?
間取り(まどり) means a floor plan, layout, or room arrangement of a home or apartment.
So この間取り means this floor plan or this layout.
There is no particle between この and 間取り because この directly modifies the noun, just like this in English:
- この本 = this book
- この部屋 = this room
- この間取り = this floor plan
What does なら mean in この間取りなら?
Here, なら means something like:
- if it’s this floor plan
- given this floor plan
- as for this layout
It sets up the condition or basis for the judgment that follows.
So この間取りなら means the speaker is saying: If we're talking about this particular layout, then...
This なら often has the nuance of making a judgment based on the topic just mentioned or just observed.
Why is it 二人で and not 二人が?
In 二人で住む, the particle で shows the group involved in doing the action together.
So 二人で住む means: to live together as two people or for two people to live there
This use of で is common with numbers of people:
- 一人で行く = go alone
- 三人で食べる = three people eat together
- 二人で住む = two people live together
If you said 二人が住む, it would focus more on two people as the grammatical subject. That is possible in some contexts, but 二人で住む is the more natural way to say live there as two people / live together as a pair.
What is the role of 住んでも here?
住んでも is 住んで + も, from the verb 住む.
The pattern て + も often means:
- even if ...
- even when ...
- even with ... doing ...
So 二人で住んでも means: even if two people live there or more naturally in this sentence: even with two people living there
The point is that the speaker is evaluating the space under that condition.
Is the も in 住んでも the same も as also?
It is the same particle も, but here it is part of the grammar pattern ても, which has a different function.
Compare:
- 私も行く = I will go too
- 行ってもいい = it’s okay to go
- 住んでも狭くなさそう = even if people live there, it doesn’t seem cramped
So in this sentence, も is not simply also. It helps form the conditional meaning even if / even when.
How does あまり work here?
あまり is commonly used with a negative expression to mean:
- not very
- not much
- not particularly
So:
- あまり狭くない = not very cramped
- あまり高くない = not very expensive
- あまり好きじゃない = don’t like it very much
In your sentence, the negative idea is inside 狭くなさそう (doesn’t seem narrow/cramped), so あまり means:
doesn’t seem very cramped
A positive sentence like あまり狭い would sound unnatural.
Why is it 狭くなさそう? How is that formed?
狭くなさそう means doesn’t seem narrow/cramped.
It comes from the negative form of the adjective 狭い:
- 狭い = narrow, cramped
- 狭くない = not narrow, not cramped
Then that negative expression is combined with そう (seems), giving:
- 狭くなさそう = seems not cramped
A useful pattern is:
- i-adjective → 〜くなさそう
- 高い → 高くなさそう = doesn’t seem expensive
- 難しい → 難しくなさそう = doesn’t seem difficult
So 狭くなさそう is a very natural way to say it doesn’t look very cramped.
What kind of そうだ is this? Is it hearsay?
This is not the hearsay そうだ.
Japanese has two common そうだ patterns:
Hearsay そうだ = I hear that... / they say that...
- 雨が降るそうだ = I hear it will rain
Appearance/seeming そうだ = looks... / seems...
- おいしそうだ = looks delicious
- 狭くなさそうだ = doesn’t seem cramped
In your sentence, it is the second one: appearance/judgment.
The speaker is judging based on what they see or think, not reporting what someone else said.
Why is there a だ at the end?
The final だ makes the sentence a plain-style statement.
So:
- 狭くなさそうだ = it seems not cramped
- 狭くなさそうです = it seems not cramped (polite)
In casual speech, the だ is sometimes omitted:
- 狭くなさそう But in written or spoken plain style, だ is very common.
What is the overall structure of the sentence?
A helpful breakdown is:
- なるほど、 = I see...
- この間取りなら = if it’s this floor plan / given this layout
- 二人で住んでも = even if two people live there
- あまり狭くなさそうだ = it doesn’t seem very cramped
So the logic is:
I see. Given this layout, even if two people live there, it doesn’t seem very cramped.
The sentence is making a judgment based on the layout.
Is 狭い literally just narrow, or does it mean something stronger here?
Literally, 狭い means narrow. But with homes, rooms, apartments, and living space, it often means:
- small
- cramped
- tight
So in this sentence, 狭くなさそう is more naturally understood as: doesn’t seem too cramped rather than only doesn’t seem narrow.
That is a very common nuance when talking about housing.
Why is there no explicit subject like it or the apartment?
Japanese often leaves out subjects and other information when they are obvious from context.
Here, the thing being judged is understood from この間取り: the apartment/room/place with this floor plan.
So instead of saying something like: This apartment doesn’t seem very cramped Japanese just says: この間取りなら…狭くなさそうだ
This is very normal Japanese. The listener is expected to understand what is being talked about from context.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from naruhodo, kono madori nara hutari de sunde mo amari semaku nasasou da to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions