Breakdown of Esatto, eravamo vicino alla finestra.
Questions & Answers about Esatto, eravamo vicino alla finestra.
What does Esatto mean at the beginning of the sentence?
What tense is eravamo?
Eravamo is the imperfetto of essere. It means we were.
The imperfect forms of essere are:
- ero = I was
- eri = you were
- era = he/she/it was
- eravamo = we were
- eravate = you were
- erano = they were
Why is eravamo used instead of siamo stati?
Eravamo gives a background description or an ongoing state in the past: we were near the window.
Italian often uses the imperfect for:
- descriptions
- situations in progress
- scene-setting in past narration
Siamo stati would sound more like a completed past fact, with more emphasis on the whole event rather than the background situation.
So if someone is recalling where people were in a scene, eravamo is very natural.
Why is there no noi in the sentence?
Because Italian usually drops subject pronouns when the verb ending already shows who the subject is. Eravamo already tells you the subject is we.
You can say Noi eravamo vicino alla finestra, but adding noi gives extra emphasis, contrast, or clarification.
What does alla mean, and how is it formed?
Why do we say vicino alla finestra and not vicino la finestra?
Because vicino normally goes with the preposition a when it means near.
The pattern is:
vicino a + noun
So:
- vicino a casa
- vicino al museo
- vicino alla finestra
That is why alla is needed here: it includes the a required by vicino.
Why isn't it vicina if finestra is feminine?
Because vicino does not describe finestra here. It describes the people who were near the window.
So if it agrees, it agrees with the subject, not with finestra:
- vicini for a masculine or mixed group
- vicine for an all-female group
So the agreeing versions would be:
- Eravamo vicini alla finestra
- Eravamo vicine alla finestra
Not vicina, because that would incorrectly make it agree with finestra.
So is eravamo vicini alla finestra more correct than eravamo vicino alla finestra?
In careful, textbook-style grammar, many teachers would prefer eravamo vicini/vicine alla finestra, with agreement.
However, in modern Italian, vicino a is also very often used in an invariable way, especially in speech, so eravamo vicino alla finestra is also common and easily understood.
A useful learner rule is:
- use vicini/vicine if you want the clearest standard agreement
- be aware that vicino a without agreement is also common in real Italian
Could I also say accanto alla finestra?
Yes. Accanto alla finestra means next to the window and is often a little more specific than vicino alla finestra.
- vicino alla finestra = near the window
- accanto alla finestra = right next to / beside the window
So both are possible, but accanto suggests closer physical position.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning ItalianMaster Italian — from Esatto, eravamo vicino alla finestra to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions