L'esercente risponde, cosa che chiarisce la discrepanza.

Breakdown of L'esercente risponde, cosa che chiarisce la discrepanza.

rispondere
to answer
cosa che
which
chiarire
to clear up
l'esercente
the merchant
la discrepanza
the discrepancy

Questions & Answers about L'esercente risponde, cosa che chiarisce la discrepanza.

Why is it l'esercente and not il esercente?

Because esercente begins with a vowel, il becomes l' before it:

  • il ragazzo
  • l'amico
  • l'esercente

So l'esercente simply means the shopkeeper / the merchant / the business owner, depending on context.

What does esercente mean exactly?

Esercente usually refers to a person who runs a business, especially a shop or commercial activity. In many contexts, it can be translated as:

  • shopkeeper
  • store owner
  • merchant
  • business operator

The most natural English choice depends on the situation. It is a somewhat formal or administrative word compared with very basic everyday nouns like negoziante.

Why is risponde used here?

Risponde is the third person singular present tense of rispondere (to answer / to reply).

So:

  • io rispondo = I answer
  • tu rispondi = you answer
  • lui/lei risponde = he/she answers

Here, the subject is l'esercente, which is singular, so risponde is the correct form.

Why is there a comma before cosa che chiarisce la discrepanza?

The comma separates the main clause from a relative comment clause:

  • L'esercente risponde = The shopkeeper replies
  • cosa che chiarisce la discrepanza = which clarifies the discrepancy

This second part comments on the whole previous idea, not just on one noun. In English, this works a bit like:

  • ..., which clarifies the discrepancy.

So the comma is important because it marks that extra explanatory clause.

What does cosa che mean here?

In this sentence, cosa che means something like:

  • which
  • and this
  • something that

It refers to the entire previous action: the shopkeeper replies. So the idea is:

  • The shopkeeper replies, which clarifies the discrepancy.

Italian often uses cosa che to refer back to a whole clause, especially in slightly formal writing.

Could Italian use just che instead of cosa che here?

Not naturally in this sentence.

If you said:

  • L'esercente risponde, che chiarisce la discrepanza

that would sound wrong or at least very unnatural, because che normally needs a clear noun antecedent. Here, the speaker wants to refer to the whole previous statement, not to a single noun.

That is why Italian uses expressions like:

Both can mean which / and this, referring to an entire preceding idea.

What is the difference between cosa che and il che?

Both can refer to a whole previous clause, but il che is usually more formal and more typical of careful written Italian.

So you may find both:

  • L'esercente risponde, cosa che chiarisce la discrepanza.
  • L'esercente risponde, il che chiarisce la discrepanza.

Both mean roughly:

  • The shopkeeper replies, which clarifies the discrepancy.

Very roughly:

  • cosa che = a little more straightforward
  • il che = a little more literary/formal
Why is it chiarisce and not chiarendo or another form?

Chiarisce is the present indicative, third person singular, from chiarire (to clarify / make clear).

The subject of chiarisce is the whole idea expressed by cosa che. So:

  • cosa che chiarisce = which clarifies

Italian uses a normal finite verb here, just as English does in which clarifies.

What does discrepanza mean, and is it a common word?

Discrepanza means:

  • discrepancy
  • difference
  • inconsistency
  • mismatch

It is a fairly common word, especially in formal, administrative, professional, or analytical contexts.

Examples:

  • C'è una discrepanza nei dati. = There is a discrepancy in the data.
  • La spiegazione elimina la discrepanza. = The explanation removes the discrepancy.

It is less conversational than a simple word like differenza, but very useful.

Is the whole sentence in the present tense even if it could describe a past event?

Yes, grammatically it is in the present tense:

  • risponde = replies / answers
  • chiarisce = clarifies

Italian, like English, can sometimes use the present to describe something in a vivid or general way, especially in summaries, explanations, or narration.

If you wanted a past version, you could say for example:

  • L'esercente ha risposto, cosa che ha chiarito la discrepanza.
Is esercente masculine or feminine here?

As written, l'esercente could refer to either a man or a woman, because the article l' does not show gender before a vowel.

The noun esercente can be used for both genders in many contexts. Usually, the gender becomes clear from:

For example:

  • L'esercente è arrivato. = the shopkeeper is male
  • L'esercente è arrivata. = the shopkeeper is female
Would this sentence sound natural in everyday spoken Italian?

It is understandable and correct, but it sounds a bit formal or written, especially because of:

In everyday speech, people might choose simpler wording depending on context. For example, they might say something more direct, such as:

  • Il negoziante risponde e questo chiarisce la differenza.

But the original sentence is perfectly good Italian, especially in formal or explanatory contexts.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“What's the best way to learn Italian grammar?”
Italian grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Italian

Master Italian — from L'esercente risponde, cosa che chiarisce la discrepanza to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions