Question 1

In Saat menunggu, who is doing the waiting?

Accepted Answer

In reduced clauses like saat menunggu, the subject is understood to be the same as the main clause’s subject. So it’s the beberapa peserta who are waiting. To make it explicit, you can say Saat para peserta menunggu, ... or Saat kami menunggu, ... depending on context.

Question 2

Why is there a comma after Saat menunggu? Is it required?

Accepted Answer

When a time/condition clause comes first, standard Indonesian puts a comma after it. It’s not strictly required in casual writing, but it improves clarity and is expected in formal text.

Question 3

Can I replace saat with ketika or waktu? Any nuance?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Ketika is a near-synonym and works in most contexts; waktu is more informal. Saat often feels slightly more formal or literary. All three fit here: Saat/Ketika/Waktu menunggu, ...

Question 4

What about sementara and sambil? Which one fits here?

Accepted Answer

- Sementara = “while/meanwhile.” Sementara menunggu, ... is fine and neutral.
- Sambil = “while (doing two actions at once) by the same subject.” Sambil menunggu, beberapa peserta membeli pisang means they bought bananas as they were waiting.

Question 5

Does beberapa already make peserta plural? Should I add para or reduplication?

Accepted Answer

Beberapa already implies plural. Don’t add para here—beberapa para peserta is ungrammatical. Avoid peserta-peserta with beberapa; beberapa peserta is the natural choice. If you mean “the participants” in general, use para peserta (without beberapa).

Question 6

Can I say beberapa orang peserta?

Accepted Answer

It’s possible but usually unnecessary. With numerals, tiga orang peserta is standard. With beberapa, most people simply say beberapa peserta; beberapa orang peserta can sound wordy unless you want to stress “people.”

Question 7

What’s the difference between lapar, kelaparan, and merasa lapar?

Accepted Answer

- lapar = hungry (neutral state).
- kelaparan = starving/very hungry; also a noun meaning “starvation” in other contexts.
- merasa lapar = to feel hungry (emphasizes the subjective feeling).
In the sentence, kelaparan means they became very hungry.

Question 8

Is kelaparan an adjective or a verb here?

Accepted Answer

It’s a stative predicate formed with ke- -an, functioning like “to be starving/very hungry.” Indonesian doesn’t strictly split adjectives and stative verbs; beberapa peserta kelaparan is a complete clause meaning “some participants were starving.” As a noun, kelaparan can also mean “starvation.”

Question 9

Is dan the best connector here, or should I use something else to show sequence/causality?

Accepted Answer

Dan works and often implies sequence from context. To make the order/logic explicit:
- Sequence: ... kelaparan lalu/kemudian membeli pisang.
- Cause: Karena kelaparan, beberapa peserta membeli pisang.
- Change-of-state: ... menjadi lapar lalu membeli pisang.

Question 10

Does membeli need an object? Could I omit pisang?

Accepted Answer

Membeli is transitive and normally takes an object. Omitting the object sounds incomplete unless it’s obvious from context. Here, pisang is the needed direct object.

Question 11

Why membeli and menunggu, not beli and nunggu?

Accepted Answer

The meN- prefix forms active verbs: beli → membeli; tunggu → menunggu (the initial t of tunggu drops with this prefix). In casual speech, base forms beli/nunggu are very common. In neutral/formal writing, membeli/menunggu is preferred.

Question 12

How do I specify how many bananas they bought?

Accepted Answer

- Numbers: membeli dua pisang.
- With a classifier: beberapa buah pisang, dua buah pisang (both are fine).
- For banana groupings: satu sisir pisang (a hand), satu tandan pisang (a whole bunch).
Avoid pisang-pisang for mere plurality; use banyak pisang for “many bananas.”

Question 13

Could beberapa peserta kelaparan mean “several starving participants” (as an attribute), not “were starving”?

Accepted Answer

Out of context it could be read either way, but here it’s clearly predicative because it’s coordinated with a verb (... dan membeli ...). To make an attributive reading explicit, use yang: beberapa peserta yang kelaparan membeli pisang (“the hungry participants bought bananas”).

Question 14

Can I add sedang to emphasize the ongoing action: Saat sedang menunggu?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Saat sedang menunggu, ... is natural and underscores the ongoing nature of the waiting. Saat menunggu already implies simultaneity; sedang just adds emphasis.

Question 15

How would I say it in passive voice?

Accepted Answer

You can focus on the bananas: Saat menunggu, pisang dibeli oleh beberapa peserta. It’s grammatical but sounds formal/report-like. The active voice with beberapa peserta as subject is more natural here.

Question 16

How do I show it happened in the past?

Accepted Answer

Indonesian doesn’t inflect for tense. Use time/aspect markers:
- tadi (earlier): Saat menunggu tadi, ...
- sudah/telah (already; telah is formal): ... sudah/telah membeli pisang.
- Add a time expression: Kemarin saat menunggu, ...

Question 17

Does menunggu need an object (like “wait for”)? Is saat menunggu okay by itself?

Accepted Answer

Menunggu can be intransitive or transitive. Both menunggu (“to wait”) and menunggu bus (“to wait for the bus”) are fine. The reduced clause saat menunggu is perfectly acceptable without an object.

Saat menunggu, beberapa peserta kelaparan dan membeli pisang.

Breakdown of Saat menunggu, beberapa peserta kelaparan dan membeli pisang.

Questions & Answers about Saat menunggu, beberapa peserta kelaparan dan membeli pisang.

More from this lesson

Master Indonesian — from Saat menunggu, beberapa peserta kelaparan dan membeli pisang to fluency