Breakdown of A könyv a polcon van, a kabát pedig a szekrényben.
Questions & Answers about A könyv a polcon van, a kabát pedig a szekrényben.
Why does the sentence use a so many times?
Because a is the Hungarian definite article, meaning the.
In this sentence:
- a könyv = the book
- a polcon = on the shelf literally on the shelf
- a kabát = the coat
- a szekrényben = in the wardrobe / closet
Hungarian usually repeats the article where English might also use the. The form a is used before words beginning with a consonant. Before a vowel, Hungarian uses az instead.
Why is it polcon but szekrényben?
These are two different location endings:
- -on / -en / -ön = on
- -ban / -ben = in
So:
- polc = shelf
- polcon = on the shelf
and:
- szekrény = wardrobe / closet / cabinet
- szekrényben = in the wardrobe
Hungarian often expresses ideas like on, in, at with noun endings rather than separate prepositions.
Why do those endings have different forms, like -on and -ben instead of just one fixed ending?
That is because of vowel harmony, a major feature of Hungarian.
Very roughly:
- words with back vowels tend to take endings like -ban, -on
- words with front vowels tend to take endings like -ben, -en, -ön
Here:
- polc contains o, a back vowel, so it becomes polcon
- szekrény contains front vowels, so it becomes szekrényben
You do not need to memorize every form separately, but you do need to get used to matching the suffix to the vowels in the word.
Why is the book on the shelf but the coat in the wardrobe?
Because Hungarian chooses the location ending based on the kind of space involved, much like English does.
- A shelf is treated as a surface, so Hungarian uses -on/-en/-ön
- A wardrobe/closet is treated as an inside space, so Hungarian uses -ban/-ben
So the choice is about meaning:
- polcon = on a surface
- szekrényben = inside something
What does pedig mean here?
Pedig is a conjunction that often means something like:
- and
- while
- whereas
- as for
- and as for
In this sentence, it connects the second clause and adds a slight contrast or topic shift:
- The book is on the shelf, and/as for the coat, it is in the wardrobe.
It is not exactly the same as és (and).
Pedig often sounds a little more contrastive or comparative.
Could I replace pedig with és?
Yes, you could say:
A könyv a polcon van, és a kabát a szekrényben van.
That would still be correct. But the nuance is a bit different:
- és = plain and
- pedig = and/while/as for, often with contrast or comparison
So pedig is very natural here because the sentence is comparing the locations of two different things.
Why is van only written once? Shouldn’t it appear in both parts?
The full version could be:
A könyv a polcon van, a kabát pedig a szekrényben van.
In the original sentence, the second van is omitted because it is already understood. This is a very normal kind of ellipsis in Hungarian, especially when the same verb would just be repeated.
So both are possible:
- ... a szekrényben. = more concise
- ... a szekrényben van. = fuller, also correct
Why is van needed at all? I thought Hungarian often leaves out is/am/are.
That is a very common and very good question.
In Hungarian, the present-tense third-person form of to be is often omitted with noun and adjective predicates:
- A könyv érdekes. = The book is interesting.
- Ő tanár. = He/She is a teacher.
But with location, Hungarian normally uses van:
- A könyv a polcon van. = The book is on the shelf.
So:
- adjective/noun predicate → often no van
- location → usually van
Why is the word order A könyv a polcon van?
This is a normal neutral Hungarian word order for a sentence about location:
- A könyv = topic, what we are talking about
- a polcon = where it is
- van = is
So the pattern is roughly:
[topic] + [location] + van
Hungarian word order is flexible, but different orders create different emphasis.
For example:
- A könyv a polcon van. = neutral
- A polcon van a könyv. = stronger emphasis on where the book is
The sentence you were given is the natural neutral version.
Are the accent marks important in words like könyv, kabát, and szekrényben?
Yes, very important.
In Hungarian, accent marks are not optional spelling decorations. They show real differences in:
- vowel quality
- often vowel length
For example:
- a and á are different vowels
- o and ö are different vowels
- e and é are different vowels
So you should learn and write them carefully:
- könyv, not konyv
- kabát, not kabat
- szekrény, not szekreny
Leaving them out can make the word incorrect or harder to understand.
Is A könyv a polcon van literally The book on the shelf is?
Yes, if you follow the Hungarian word order very closely, it looks like that.
Hungarian does not arrange the sentence the same way English does. A very literal breakdown is:
- A könyv = the book
- a polcon = on the shelf
- van = is
So literally it is something like:
The book on the shelf is.
But in normal English, we say:
The book is on the shelf.
This is a good example of why it is better to understand Hungarian sentence structure directly, instead of translating word by word.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning HungarianMaster Hungarian — from A könyv a polcon van, a kabát pedig a szekrényben to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions