Word
An der Garderobe liegt ein Stapel Schals, die niemand abgeholt hat.
Meaning
At the coat rack there is a pile of scarves that nobody picked up.
Part of speech
sentence
Pronunciation
Course
Lesson
Breakdown of An der Garderobe liegt ein Stapel Schals, die niemand abgeholt hat.
liegen
to lie
niemand
nobody
abholen
to pick up (collect)
an
at
Questions & Answers about An der Garderobe liegt ein Stapel Schals, die niemand abgeholt hat.
Why is it an der Garderobe and not an die Garderobe? Which case does an take here?
An is a two-way preposition. It takes:
- the dative for location (where something is): an der Garderobe = at the coat check.
- the accusative for direction (movement to): an die Garderobe = to the coat check (e.g., bring something there).
Here it’s a static location, so dative: der Garderobe.
Why can’t I say am Garderobe?
Am is the contraction of an dem (an + dem), which is only possible with masculine or neuter nouns. Garderobe is feminine (die Garderobe), so you must use an der Garderobe, not am Garderobe.
Why does the verb come before the subject: An der Garderobe liegt ein Stapel Schals?
German is a V2 language: exactly one element can stand before the finite verb. The prepositional phrase An der Garderobe is put in first position for emphasis (location), so the verb liegt must be second, and the subject ein Stapel Schals follows. The neutral order is also possible: Ein Stapel Schals liegt an der Garderobe.
Why is it liegt (singular) and not liegen (plural)?
The grammatical subject is ein Stapel (a pile), which is singular, so the verb is singular: liegt. The word Schals belongs to the noun phrase headed by Stapel; it doesn’t determine verb agreement in the main clause.
What is the function of die after the comma?