Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Unser Plan ist heute anders.
What case is Plan in, and why?
Nominative, because it’s the subject of the copular verb ist. With sein, the subject is nominative: "Der Plan ist anders." With a possessive determiner, it remains nominative: Unser Plan ist anders.
Why is it "Unser Plan" and not "unsere/unsers/unseren Plan"?
Because Plan is masculine singular nominative. Possessive determiners (mein, dein, unser, etc.) behave like ein-words: masculine nominative has no ending, hence unser Plan. Quick guide:
- feminine nominative/plural → unsere
- neuter nominative/accusative → unser
- masculine accusative → unseren
- dative masc/neut → unserem
- genitive masc/neut → unseres
- dative fem/gen fem/pl → unserer
What is "anders" here—an adjective or an adverb?
It functions as a predicative adjective (a predicate complement). After sein, adjectives appear in base form (no ending): Der Plan ist anders. It describes the subject’s state, not a noun directly, so no ending is added.
How is "anders" different from "andere/anderes" and from "anders als"?
- anders: predicative/complement use — Der Plan ist anders.
- andere/anderes/anderen …: attributive before a noun — ein anderer Plan, andere Pläne.
- anders als + NP/clause: explicit comparison — Unser Plan ist heute anders als gestern / … anders als deiner.
Can I put "heute" somewhere else? What changes if I move it?
Yes. All are grammatical, with different emphasis:
- Unser Plan ist heute anders. Neutral; mild focus on time.
- Heute ist unser Plan anders. Stronger focus on “today.”
- Unser Plan ist anders heute. Possible in speech for end-focus, but less neutral; avoid in formal writing.
Why is the verb in second position—"ist" after "Unser Plan"?
German main clauses are verb-second (V2). The whole subject phrase Unser Plan occupies the first position, and the finite verb ist must come next. If you front Heute, you still keep V2: Heute ist unser Plan anders.
Do I need an article before "Plan" even though there’s a possessive?
No. Possessive determiners replace the article: unser Plan, not der unser Plan. Adding an article here is nonstandard in German.
Is "Unser Plan ist heute unterschiedlich" correct?
Not idiomatic for a single plan. unterschiedlich/verschieden describe multiple things: Die Pläne sind unterschiedlich. For one thing being different compared to something else, use anders or anders als …: Unser Plan ist heute anders (als sonst).
Do I need to say what it’s different from? Should I add "als …"?
Not required. German often leaves the comparison implicit (than usual/previously). To be explicit, add:
- … anders als sonst/üblich/früher/gestern.
- … anders als geplant/erwartet.
How would I say "We have a different plan today"?
Use an attributive adjective:
- Wir haben heute einen anderen Plan. This stresses possession of a different plan. The original sentence states the plan’s current state.
What’s the difference between "ist heute anders", "wird heute anders sein", and "hat sich heute geändert"?
- ist heute anders: describes the current situation now.
- wird heute anders sein: prediction or schedule for later today/future.
- hat sich heute geändert: focuses on the change event that occurred today.
Why is "Plan" capitalized but "heute" and "anders" lowercase?
All nouns are capitalized in German (Plan). Adjectives and adverbs are lowercase unless substantivized or sentence-initial. So heute (adverb) and anders (predicative adjective) stay lowercase.
Could I say "Unsere Pläne sind heute anders" or "Wir haben heute andere Pläne"?
Yes.
- Unsere Pläne sind heute anders. Plural subject with predicative anders.
- Wir haben heute andere Pläne. Attributive andere before the plural noun. The second is very common in everyday speech.
Is "Plan" the right word, or should it be "Planung"?
- Plan = a specific plan/schedule/intent (countable).
- Planung = the planning process/activity (usually uncountable). Here you mean the concrete plan, so Plan is correct.
How do I pronounce "Unser Plan ist heute anders"?
Approximate IPA: [ˈʊnzɐ plaːn ɪst ˈhɔʏ̯tə ˈandɐs].
- unser: first syllable stressed; light final -r.
- heute: diphthong [ɔʏ̯] like the English diphthong in boy.
- anders: stress on first syllable; final -s is unvoiced [s].
How do I negate or ask a question with this sentence?
- Negation: Unser Plan ist heute nicht anders.
- Yes/no question: Ist unser Plan heute anders?
- Wh-question (e.g., when): Wann ist unser Plan anders? – Heute.
Is the sentence formal or informal?
Neutral. It fits both casual and formal contexts. unser simply marks first-person plural possession.
Should I say "am heute"? Why just "heute"?
Use heute without a preposition. You use am with days/dates: am Montag, am 5. Mai. So: Unser Plan ist heute anders, but Unser Plan ist am Montag anders.
Can I say "Unser Plan ist heute ein anderer"?
Yes. That uses a predicate noun phrase with attributive anderer (masc. nominative). It makes it explicit that it’s a different plan (another one), not just different in some aspects.