Breakdown of Diese Aufgabe ist kompliziert, aber deine Methode ist nützlich.
sein
to be
aber
but
diese
this
deine
your
die Aufgabe
the task
kompliziert
complicated
die Methode
the method
nützlich
useful
Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Diese Aufgabe ist kompliziert, aber deine Methode ist nützlich.
Why is kompliziert not inflected with an adjective ending?
Because it’s used predicatively after the verb sein. Predicative adjectives in German remain uninflected, so you simply say ... ist kompliziert rather than adding an ending.
Why is there a comma before aber?
In German, two main clauses joined by a coordinating conjunction like aber must be separated by a comma: Diese Aufgabe ist kompliziert, aber ….
What is the gender of Aufgabe, and why do we use diese here?
Aufgabe is a feminine noun. In the nominative singular, the feminine demonstrative pronoun is diese (“this”), so diese Aufgabe = “this task.”
Why is it deine Methode and not dein Methode?
Methode is feminine, so the possessive pronoun must agree in gender, number, and case: feminine nominative singular → deine Methode.
What’s the difference between kompliziert and komplex in German?
Both can mean “complicated” or “complex,” but komplex often emphasizes many interconnected parts, while kompliziert stresses that something is difficult or intricate to understand.
Why doesn’t aber cause inversion of the verb in the second clause?
aber is a coordinating conjunction (like und, oder, denn). Coordinating conjunctions do not affect the normal subject-verb order, so you keep S-V-O.
Why do we repeat the verb ist in both clauses? Could we drop it in the second?
Each independent clause in German needs its own finite verb. You cannot omit ist in the second clause; you must say …, aber deine Methode ist nützlich.
How would you use kompliziert and nützlich as attributive adjectives before a noun?
Attributive adjectives precede the noun and take endings. For example: eine komplizierte Aufgabe and eine nützliche Methode.
Can we replace aber with jedoch, and does the word order change?
Yes. jedoch is a more formal coordinating conjunction. You still need a comma, and the verb remains in second position: …, jedoch ist deine Methode nützlich.
How would the sentence change if we used the subordinating conjunction weil (because) instead?
With weil, the second clause becomes subordinate and the verb moves to the end:
Diese Aufgabe ist kompliziert, weil deine Methode nützlich ist.
The comma is mandatory.
What does nützlich mean in English, and what are some synonyms?
nützlich means useful or helpful. Synonyms include hilfreich (“helpful”) and praktisch (“practical”).