Breakdown of Der Brennofen muss schon ausgeschaltet worden sein.
Questions & Answers about Der Brennofen muss schon ausgeschaltet worden sein.
Here muss expresses a logical conclusion, not an obligation.
So in this sentence, muss ... gewesen/worden sein means something like:
- must have been
- must already have been
It does not mean that someone is being told to switch the kiln off. Instead, the speaker is inferring that it was already switched off.
This is a very common use of müssen in German:
- Er muss krank sein. = He must be ill.
- Sie muss schon gegangen sein. = She must already have left.
Yes. In this sentence, schon means already.
It suggests that the switching-off happened earlier than the speaker is now realizing, checking, or discussing.
So schon adds the idea:
- it had happened by that point
- perhaps sooner than expected
- or before the current moment of discovery
In everyday German, schon can have several meanings depending on context, but here already is the natural one.