Breakdown of Nous sommes dix-sept dans la salle.
Questions & Answers about Nous sommes dix-sept dans la salle.
Why does French use sommes here? Why not avons?
Because French uses être in this kind of sentence to express how many people are in a group.
So Nous sommes dix-sept literally looks like We are seventeen, but the natural meaning is There are seventeen of us or We are seventeen people.
Using avoir here would be wrong. French does not say Nous avons dix-sept to mean There are seventeen of us.
What exactly does dix-sept mean in this sentence?
Why is there no word for people after dix-sept?
Because French does not need it here.
When the subject is already a group of people, personnes is often omitted:
- Nous sommes dix-sept.
- Vous êtes combien ? — Nous sommes dix-sept.
You can say Nous sommes dix-sept personnes, but it is less necessary unless you want to be extra clear or slightly more formal.
Why is nous used instead of il y a?
Both are possible, but they do slightly different things.
- Nous sommes dix-sept dans la salle. = There are seventeen of us in the room.
- Il y a dix-sept personnes dans la salle. = There are seventeen people in the room.
The first version includes the speaker as part of the group and focuses on us.
The second version is a more neutral statement about how many people are present.
So if you are one of the seventeen, nous sommes dix-sept is very natural.
What does dans la salle mean exactly?
It means in the room, in the hall, or sometimes in the classroom, depending on context.
The noun salle is broader than English room in some cases. It can refer to:
- a room
- a hall
- a classroom
- a function room
- a larger indoor space
So the exact English translation depends on the situation.
Why is dans la salle placed at the end?
Could this sentence be said with on instead of nous?
Is dix-sept ever plural here? Should it be dix-septs?
How would a French speaker pronounce this sentence?
A careful pronunciation would be roughly:
nou som diz-set dan la sal
More precisely:
- Nous → nou
- sommes → som
- dix-sept → dis-set
- dans → nasal vowel, something like dahn
- la salle → la sal
A useful point: in dix-sept, the x is pronounced like an s sound: dis-set.
Is this sentence talking only about people physically inside the room right now?
Usually yes.
Dans la salle normally means the people are present in the room. So the sentence is typically understood as a count of the people currently there.
If the context changed, it could refer to who is in that room as a group at some given moment, but the most natural reading is simply: there are seventeen of us in the room.
Could I also say Nous sommes dix-sept dans cette salle or Nous sommes dix-sept ici?
Yes.
These are all possible, with slightly different emphasis:
- Nous sommes dix-sept dans la salle. = There are seventeen of us in the room.
- Nous sommes dix-sept dans cette salle. = There are seventeen of us in this room.
- Nous sommes dix-sept ici. = There are seventeen of us here.
They all work; the choice depends on what location you want to highlight.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Nous sommes dix-sept dans la salle to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions