Breakdown of Ma mère et ma tante s’écrivent l’une à l’autre le soir.
Questions & Answers about Ma mère et ma tante s’écrivent l’une à l’autre le soir.
Why is s’écrivent used instead of just écrivent?
Because French is showing that the action goes between the people in the subject.
The base verb is écrire = to write.
But écrire à quelqu’un means to write to someone.
So in Ma mère et ma tante s’écrivent, the s’ stands for to each other / to themselves, depending on context. Here, with two people, it means to each other.
So the idea is not just they write, but they write to each other.
Is s’ reflexive here, or does it mean each other?
Here it is reciprocal, not truly reflexive.
- Reflexive: the subject does something to itself
- Reciprocal: the people in the subject do the action to one another
So in this sentence:
Because there are two people, the natural reading is reciprocal.
Why is l’une à l’autre added if s’ already shows that they are writing to each other?
Because French often uses both forms together for clarity or emphasis.
So:
Both are possible, but the second one is more explicit: it clearly says one to the other.
This is very common with reciprocal actions in French.
Why is it l’une and not l’un?
Why is there an à in l’une à l’autre?
Because the verb écrire takes à before the person receiving the writing.
You write:
So the reciprocal expression follows that pattern:
- l’une à l’autre = to one another
This depends on the verb. For example:
- Ils se regardent l’un l’autre
because regarder quelqu’un has no à - Ils se parlent l’un à l’autre
because parler à quelqu’un uses à
So s’écrivent l’une à l’autre matches the grammar of écrire à quelqu’un.
Why does s’ come before the verb?
What does le soir mean here, and why is there a le?
Le soir usually means in the evening or in the evenings, often with a habitual sense.
In French, the definite article is often used in time expressions like this:
- le matin = in the morning
- l’après-midi = in the afternoon
- le soir = in the evening
So here, le soir suggests something like in the evenings or at night as a regular time when they write.
If you wanted this evening, you would say:
- ce soir
What tense is s’écrivent, and does it mean they are writing right now?
It is in the present tense.
But the French present tense can mean different things depending on context. Here, with le soir, it most naturally suggests a habit or regular action:
- they write to each other in the evenings
So this sentence does not strongly suggest that they are writing at this exact moment.
How would this change if the people were masculine or mixed?
The verb part would work the same way, but the reciprocal expression would usually change form.
- Two feminine people: l’une à l’autre
- Two masculine people: l’un à l’autre
- One masculine and one feminine: usually l’un à l’autre as well
So for example:
- Mon père et mon oncle s’écrivent l’un à l’autre le soir.
- Ma mère et mon oncle s’écrivent l’un à l’autre le soir.
The verb s’écrivent stays plural because there are two people in the subject.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Ma mère et ma tante s’écrivent l’une à l’autre le soir to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions