Breakdown of Depuis la dispute, ils ne se parlent plus.
Questions & Answers about Depuis la dispute, ils ne se parlent plus.
Why is depuis used here?
Depuis means since here. It gives the starting point of a situation that began in the past and is still true now.
So Depuis la dispute means since the argument.
This is a little different from après:
- Après la dispute = after the argument
- Depuis la dispute = since the argument, from then until now
The sentence is about an ongoing situation, so depuis is the natural choice.
Does dispute mean the same thing as the English word dispute?
Why is there la in la dispute?
French usually uses an article where English might not think about it as much.
Here, la dispute means the argument — a specific argument that both the speaker and listener can identify.
So French says:
- Depuis la dispute
where English naturally says:
- Since the argument
- or sometimes just Since their argument
What does se parlent mean here?
This is the verb se parler, which means to talk to each other or to speak to one another.
The basic verb is parler à quelqu’un = to speak to someone.
When the action is reciprocal, French often uses se:
- Ils se parlent = They talk to each other
So se here does not mean themselves in the usual English sense. It means each other.
Why is there no à after parlent?
Because se already takes the place of à l’un l’autre or à eux.
Compare:
- Ils parlent à leurs amis. = They are talking to their friends.
- Ils se parlent. = They are talking to each other.
With parler, the person spoken to is normally introduced by à, but when that person becomes a pronoun, French uses se here.
So Ils se parlent is basically the idea of:
- Ils parlent l’un à l’autre
What does ne... plus mean?
Ne... plus means no longer or not anymore.
So:
This is different from ne... pas:
- Ils ne se parlent pas = They are not talking to each other / they do not talk to each other
- Ils ne se parlent plus = They used to talk to each other, but now they do not
So plus adds the idea of a change from an earlier situation.
Why is the word order ne se parlent plus?
In French negation, ne comes before the verb phrase and plus comes after the conjugated verb.
With a pronominal verb like se parler, the reflexive/reciprocal pronoun stays right before the verb.
So the pattern is:
subject + ne + pronoun + verb + plus
Here:
- ils = subject
- ne = first part of negation
- se = pronoun
- parlent = verb
- plus = second part of negation
That gives:
- ils ne se parlent plus
Why is parlent in the present tense if the argument happened in the past?
Because French often uses the present tense with depuis when a situation started in the past and still continues now.
So:
- the argument happened in the past
- their not speaking is still true now
That is why French says:
English often uses different wording, such as:
- They haven’t spoken to each other since the argument
- Since the argument, they no longer speak to each other
But in French, the present tense is completely normal here.
Could I also say Depuis qu'ils se sont disputés?
Yes. That is a very natural alternative.
- Depuis la dispute = Since the argument
- Depuis qu'ils se sont disputés = Since they argued / Since they had an argument
The first version uses a noun phrase. The second uses a full clause.
Both are correct. The choice depends on whether you want to name the event with a noun (la dispute) or describe it with a verb (ils se sont disputés).
Is the ne always kept in spoken French?
How is plus pronounced here?
In ne... plus meaning no longer / not anymore, plus is usually pronounced ply.
So:
The final s is usually not pronounced here.
That said, pronunciation of plus can vary depending on meaning, register, and what sound follows, so the safest thing for a learner is to remember this sentence as a fixed pattern:
- ne... plus = no longer / not anymore
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Depuis la dispute, ils ne se parlent plus to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions