Breakdown of Ma fille répond que ce jouet en solde lui plaît le plus.
Questions & Answers about Ma fille répond que ce jouet en solde lui plaît le plus.
Why is it répond and not réponds?
Because ma fille is third-person singular: my daughter / she.
The present tense of répondre goes like this:
- je réponds
- tu réponds
- il / elle répond
- nous répondons
- vous répondez
- ils / elles répondent
So with ma fille, you need répond.
What does que do in this sentence?
Here que means that and introduces a new clause:
- Ma fille répond = My daughter answers
- que ce jouet en solde lui plaît le plus = that this toy on sale pleases her the most
So que is a conjunction, not a question word here.
English often drops that, but French usually keeps que:
- She says that...
- Elle dit que...
The same thing is happening with répond:
- She answers that...
- Elle répond que...
Why is it ce jouet and not cet jouet?
Because jouet is a masculine singular noun that begins with a consonant sound.
French uses:
- ce before masculine singular nouns starting with a consonant sound
- ce livre
- ce jouet
- cet before masculine singular nouns starting with a vowel sound or mute h
- cet ami
- cet hôtel
- cette for feminine singular
- cette voiture
So jouet takes ce.
What does en solde mean here?
En solde means on sale, discounted, or marked down.
So:
- ce jouet en solde = this toy on sale
It is a common French expression. It comes after the noun, which is normal in French for many descriptive phrases.
Compare:
- un jouet en solde = a toy on sale
- des jouets en solde = toys on sale
Notice that en solde stays the same form.
Why is en solde after jouet instead of before it?
In French, many descriptive elements come after the noun.
English often says:
- this discounted toy
French often prefers:
- ce jouet en solde
So instead of putting everything before the noun, French frequently uses a phrase after it.
You can think of en solde as a short descriptive expression attached to jouet.
Why is it lui plaît? What does lui mean?
Here lui means to her.
The verb plaire works differently from English to like.
French structure:
- ce jouet plaît à ma fille
= this toy pleases my daughter
When à ma fille is replaced by a pronoun, it becomes lui:
- ce jouet lui plaît
= this toy pleases her
= she likes this toy
So lui is an indirect object pronoun.
Why doesn’t French use something like elle aime here?
French can use aimer, but plaire has a different structure and a slightly different feel.
- Elle aime ce jouet = She likes/loves this toy
- Ce jouet lui plaît = This toy pleases her / She likes this toy
With plaire, the thing liked becomes the grammatical subject:
- ce jouet = the thing doing the pleasing
- lui = the person who feels pleased
This is one of the most important things to notice in the sentence:
French is not saying she likes the toy in the same structure as English.
It is saying the toy pleases her.
Why is it lui and not la?
Because plaire takes à before the person:
- plaire à quelqu’un = to please someone
That means the person is an indirect object, not a direct object.
So:
- à ma fille → lui
- not la
Compare:
- Je vois ma fille → Je la vois
because voir takes a direct object - Ce jouet plaît à ma fille → Ce jouet lui plaît
because plaire takes an indirect object
What does le plus mean here?
Le plus means the most.
So:
- ce jouet lui plaît le plus = this toy pleases her the most
- more naturally in English: she likes this toy the most
This is a superlative. It suggests there are several toys or options, and this one is her favorite among them.
Compare:
- plus = more
- le plus = the most
Examples:
- Ce jouet lui plaît plus que l’autre. = She likes this toy more than the other one.
- Ce jouet lui plaît le plus. = She likes this toy the most.
What exactly is being compared by le plus?
It usually means among a group of possible choices, this is the one she likes most.
So the sentence implies something like:
- among the toys
- among the sale items
- among the available options
French does not need to say the full comparison if it is clear from context.
If you wanted to be more explicit, you could say something like:
- Ce jouet est celui qui lui plaît le plus.
= This toy is the one she likes the most.
But the original sentence is perfectly normal if the comparison set is already understood.
Why is lui placed before plaît?
Because French object pronouns normally come before the conjugated verb.
So:
- Ce jouet plaît à ma fille
becomes - Ce jouet lui plaît
The order is:
- subject: ce jouet
- pronoun: lui
- verb: plaît
This placement is very common in French:
- Je lui parle
- Elle me voit
- Nous vous répondons
So once à ma fille becomes lui, it moves in front of the verb.
How is plaît pronounced, and why does it have an accent?
Plaît is pronounced roughly like play in English, though with a French vowel quality.
It comes from the verb plaire.
The accent mark is part of the standard spelling:
- il plaît
You may also see that the circumflex in forms like plaît is sometimes omitted in spelling reforms, but plaît is still the traditional and very common spelling.
A rough pronunciation of the whole sentence is:
- Ma fille répond que ce jouet en solde lui plaît le plus
- roughly: ma fee-yuh ray-pon kuh suh zhway ahn sold lwee play luh ploo
That is only an approximation, but it can help you get started.
Can répond really be followed directly by que?
Yes. Répondre can introduce reported speech with que.
Examples:
- Il répond qu’il est prêt. = He answers that he is ready.
- Elle répond que non. = She answers no.
- Ma fille répond que ce jouet en solde lui plaît le plus.
If you want to mention the person being answered, you can add à:
- Ma fille répond à sa mère que...
= My daughter answers her mother that...
So répond que is completely normal French.
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Ma fille répond que ce jouet en solde lui plaît le plus to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions