Question 1

What is the function of celui in this sentence, and how would you translate it?

Accepted Answer

celui is a masculine singular demonstrative pronoun meaning “the one” or “he who.” It replaces a noun (e.g. “man” or “person”) and introduces the specific individual. Here, Celui qui chante dans le jardin translates as “The one who sings in the garden…”.

Question 2

Why is qui used as the relative pronoun instead of que?

Accepted Answer

qui functions as the subject of the verb in the relative clause. In qui chante, qui performs the action “sings.” If the pronoun were the direct object, you would use que instead.

Question 3

Can we use que with celui in another example?

Accepted Answer

Yes. For example:  
• Celui que j’ai vu dans le jardin – “The one that I saw in the garden.”  
Here que is the direct object of voir.

Question 4

What tense is chante, and why isn’t it chanté?

Accepted Answer

chante is the 3rd person singular present indicative of chanter (“to sing”). chanté is the past participle and only appears in compound tenses (e.g., a chanté = “has sung”).

Question 5

Why is there a le in dans le jardin? Could you drop it?

Accepted Answer

French normally requires an article before a singular, countable noun. dans le jardin means “in the garden,” specifying which garden. Omitting le (i.e., dans jardin) would be ungrammatical.

Question 6

Why is it mon ami and not un ami or le mon ami?

Accepted Answer

Possessive adjectives (mon, ton, son, etc.) replace the indefinite or definite article.  
• mon ami = “my friend.”  
• un ami = “a friend” (indefinite).  
• le mon ami is incorrect in French.

Question 7

If the singer were female, how would you change celui and ami?

Accepted Answer

Use the feminine forms:  
• Celle qui chante dans le jardin est mon amie.  
Note that mon amie stays mon because amie begins with a vowel, but amie takes the -e ending for feminine.

Question 8

Could you rearrange dans le jardin, for example: Celui dans le jardin qui chante?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Celui dans le jardin qui chante is grammatically correct. This order places slight emphasis on the location, translating as “The one in the garden who sings,” but the overall meaning is the same.

Celui qui chante dans le jardin est mon ami.

Breakdown of Celui qui chante dans le jardin est mon ami.

Questions & Answers about Celui qui chante dans le jardin est mon ami.

Master French — from Celui qui chante dans le jardin est mon ami to fluency