Breakdown of Il attend, non pas que Paul refuse, mais pour confirmer.
Questions & Answers about Il attend, non pas que Paul refuse, mais pour confirmer.
What does non pas ... mais ... mean?
What does non pas que mean specifically?
Non pas que is a common pattern meaning not that.... It often introduces an explanation or interpretation that the speaker wants to reject.
For example:
So in your sentence, non pas que Paul refuse presents an idea the speaker is distancing themselves from: not that Paul is refusing.
Why is it refuse after que? Is that the subjunctive?
Yes. After non pas que, French normally uses the subjunctive.
So the expected form is:
- que Paul refuse
For the verb refuser, the present subjunctive form refuse looks exactly the same as the present indicative form refuse. That is why there is no visible spelling difference here.
Compare:
- Indicative: Paul refuse
- Subjunctive: que Paul refuse
They are spelled the same, but the grammar is different.
Why is there no ne in non pas?
Who is doing the confirming in pour confirmer?
Normally, with pour + infinitive, the understood subject is the same as the subject of the main verb.
So in:
- Il attend ... pour confirmer
the most natural reading is that il is the one who will confirm.
If you wanted Paul to be the one confirming, French would normally make that clearer, for example:
depending on the intended meaning.
Why use pour confirmer instead of que ... confirme?
Pour + infinitive usually expresses purpose: in order to confirm.
So:
- pour confirmer = to confirm / in order to confirm
By contrast, que + verb introduces a full clause.
The important point is that your sentence mixes two different structures:
- non pas que Paul refuse
- mais pour confirmer
That is why it feels uneven. French usually prefers a more parallel structure after non pas ... mais ....
For example:
Those are more balanced.
Is this sentence natural French?
Not really. It is understandable, but it sounds awkward because the two parts after non pas ... mais ... are not parallel.
You have:
- que Paul refuse = a clause
- pour confirmer = an infinitive phrase of purpose
French usually prefers the two sides of this contrast to match more closely.
More natural versions would depend on the intended meaning:
Il attend, non pas que Paul refuse, mais qu’il confirme.
If the contrast is between Paul refusing and Paul confirming.Il attend, non pas pour refuser, mais pour confirmer.
If the contrast is between two purposes.Il attend, non parce que Paul refuse, mais pour confirmer.
If the intended meaning is He is waiting, not because Paul refuses, but in order to confirm.
So the original sentence is a bit grammatically mismatched.
What role does attend play here? Does attendre mean wait or expect?
Attendre can mean both to wait and to expect, depending on context.
Common patterns include:
- attendre quelqu’un = to wait for someone
- attendre quelque chose = to wait for something / expect something
- attendre que + subjunctive = to wait until / wait for someone to...
In your sentence, attend is followed by a contrastive construction, which makes the wording feel less straightforward than a simple attendre quelqu’un or attendre que... structure.
That is another reason the sentence feels slightly unnatural.
If I want to keep the idea but make the French more idiomatic, what should I do?
Try to make both halves of the contrast follow the same pattern.
Good options are:
For example:
- Il attend, non pas que Paul refuse, mais qu’il confirme.
- Il attend, non pas pour refuser, mais pour confirmer.
- Il n’attend pas un refus de Paul, mais une confirmation.
So the main improvement is parallel structure.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Il attend, non pas que Paul refuse, mais pour confirmer to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions