Breakdown of Pijan muškarac ne smije pucati.
Questions & Answers about Pijan muškarac ne smije pucati.
Why is it pijan muškarac and not pijani muškarac?
Croatian masculine adjectives can have a short form and a long form in the nominative singular.
- pijan = short form
- pijani = long form
In modern Croatian, both can appear before a noun, and both can mean drunk here. The version in your sentence, pijan muškarac, is perfectly possible. Pijani muškarac is also very common and may sound a bit fuller or more definite, depending on style and context.
So the sentence is not wrong at all; it is just using the shorter adjective form.
What case is muškarac, and how can I tell?
Muškarac is in the nominative singular because it is the subject of the sentence.
In Pijan muškarac ne smije pucati, the person doing the action is the drunk man, so Croatian uses the nominative.
You can also see agreement:
- pijan = masculine singular nominative
- muškarac = masculine singular nominative
If it were an object, the form would change, for example:
- Vidim pijanog muškarca. = I see a drunk man.
Why is there no word for a or the?
Croatian does not have articles like English a/an and the.
So muškarac can mean:
- a man
- the man
The exact meaning depends on context.
That means Pijan muškarac ne smije pucati could be understood as:
- a general statement: A drunk man must not shoot
- a specific statement: The drunk man must not shoot
Without extra context, both are possible.
What does ne smije mean exactly?
The verb smjeti means to be allowed to, may.
So:
- smije = is allowed to / may
- ne smije = is not allowed to / may not / must not
In English, the best translation is often must not, because it expresses prohibition clearly.
So this sentence is about permission/prohibition, not ability.
Why is it ne smije and not ne može?
Because smjeti and moći mean different things:
- smjeti = to be allowed to
- moći = to be able to / can
So:
- Ne smije pucati. = He must not shoot / He is not allowed to shoot.
- Ne može pucati. = He cannot shoot / He is unable to shoot.
Your sentence says the drunk man is forbidden to shoot, not that he is physically unable to.
Why is smije in that form?
Smije is the 3rd person singular present tense form of smjeti.
It is 3rd person singular because the subject is one man:
- (on) smije = he may / he is allowed to
A few present-tense forms of smjeti are:
- smijem = I may
- smiješ = you may
- smije = he/she/it may
- smijemo = we may
- smijete = you may
- smiju = they may
Why is pucati in the infinitive?
After modal verbs such as smjeti, Croatian normally uses the infinitive of the main verb.
So:
- smije pucati = may shoot
- ne smije pucati = must not shoot
This is similar to English may shoot, except Croatian does not need a separate word like to here.
Other examples:
- mora ići = must go
- može doći = can come
- želi spavati = wants to sleep
Does pucati only mean to shoot?
No. Pucati has several meanings depending on context.
It can mean:
- to shoot / fire
- to burst
- to crack / split
In this sentence, the natural meaning is to shoot, probably with a gun or firearm, because that fits the idea of prohibition: A drunk man must not shoot.
So the context tells you which meaning is intended.
Can the word order be different?
Yes. Croatian word order is more flexible than English word order.
The given sentence:
- Pijan muškarac ne smije pucati.
is a normal, clear order.
Because pijan stands directly before muškarac, it describes the noun as part of one phrase: a drunk man.
A different order can slightly change the emphasis. For example:
- Muškarac ne smije pucati pijan.
This more strongly suggests:
- A man must not shoot while drunk.
That is very close in meaning, but the focus shifts a little from a drunk man to the condition of being drunk at the time of shooting.
How would the sentence change for a woman or for more than one person?
Both the adjective and the verb have to agree.
For a woman:
- Pijana žena ne smije pucati.
For several men:
- Pijani muškarci ne smiju pucati.
Notice the changes:
- pijan → pijana / pijani
- smije → smiju in the plural
So Croatian agreement is important:
- adjective agrees with the noun
- verb agrees with the subject
Why is ne written separately from smije?
In Croatian, the negative particle ne is usually written separately from the verb.
So:
- ne smije
- ne može
- ne puca
That is the normal pattern.
A few very common forms are written together, such as:
- nisam
- nemam
But smjeti does not behave like that, so ne smije is correct.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CroatianMaster Croatian — from Pijan muškarac ne smije pucati to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions