Breakdown of jìzhě yòu wèn tā, wèishénme bú zài jiā wán yóuxì, érshì měitiān lái gōngyuán dǎ lánqiú.
Questions & Answers about jìzhě yòu wèn tā, wèishénme bú zài jiā wán yóuxì, érshì měitiān lái gōngyuán dǎ lánqiú.
What is the basic word order of this sentence?
A helpful way to break it up is:
- 记者又问她 = The reporter asked her again
- 为什么不在家玩游戏 = why she doesn’t stay home and play video games
- 而是每天来公园打篮球 = but instead comes to the park every day to play basketball
So the full structure is:
More literally, Chinese is doing something like:
- Reporter again asked her, why not at home play games, but instead every day come to the park play basketball.
That sounds unusual in English, but it is natural in Chinese.
What does 又 mean here?
Here 又 means again.
So:
- 记者问她 = The reporter asked her
- 记者又问她 = The reporter asked her again
It shows that this is not the first question the reporter asked.
A common thing for learners to remember:
- 又 often refers to something happening again
- depending on context, it can also suggest in addition or furthermore, but here again is the natural meaning
Why is 不 written as bú here instead of bù?
This is because of tone sandhi.
Normally 不 is fourth tone: bù.
But when 不 comes before another fourth-tone syllable, it changes to second tone: bú.
Here it comes before 在 zài, which is fourth tone:
- 不在 → pronounced bú zài
So the writing shows the actual pronunciation in this sentence.
Compare:
- 不来 → bù lái because 来 is second tone
- 不是 → bú shì because 是 is fourth tone
Why is there no subject after 为什么? Shouldn’t it say 为什么她不在家玩游戏?
Yes, 为什么她不在家玩游戏 would also be grammatically possible.
But in this sentence, the subject 她 is already clear from the earlier part:
- 记者又问她,为什么...
Once Chinese has already established who is being talked about, it often leaves the subject out if it is obvious from context.
So:
- 为什么不在家玩游戏,而是每天来公园打篮球 means
- Why don’t you/why doesn’t she stay home and play games, but instead come to the park every day to play basketball?
Because the person is already identified as 她, Chinese does not need to repeat it.
This kind of omission is very common in Mandarin.
Why is 为什么 used here instead of 怎么?
为什么 means why and asks for a reason.
- 为什么不在家玩游戏? = Why not stay home and play games?
怎么 usually means how, in what way, or sometimes why in a more conversational or emotional sense, but it is not the best choice here if you are asking for a reasoned explanation.
So in this sentence, 为什么 is the standard and expected word.
How does 而是 work here?
而是 means but instead.
It is used when you contrast one possibility with the real one.
Here the contrast is:
- 不在家玩游戏
- 而是每天来公园打篮球
So the idea is:
- not staying home playing video games, but instead coming to the park every day to play basketball
This is a very common pattern:
- 不是 A,而是 B = not A, but B
In your sentence, the first part is slightly shortened because it is inside a 为什么 clause:
- 为什么不...,而是...
The contrast is still the same:
- not this, but rather that
Shouldn’t it be 不是在家玩游戏,而是... instead of just 不在家玩游戏,而是...?
Both ideas are related, but the version in the sentence is natural.
In a why question, Chinese often says:
- 为什么不 A,而是 B?
- Why not A, but instead B?
This works well because the speaker is asking about the reason for choosing B instead of A.
If you said:
- 为什么不是在家玩游戏,而是...
that sounds more like:
- Why is it not the case that she is playing games at home, but instead...
That is a bit heavier and less natural here.
So 为什么不 A,而是 B is the smoother pattern in this context.
Why is 每天 placed before 来公园打篮球?
每天 means every day, and it usually comes before the verb phrase it modifies.
So:
- 每天来公园打篮球 = come to the park every day to play basketball
Chinese time words often appear before the main verb:
- 我今天去学校。 = I’m going to school today.
- 他明天回来。 = He will come back tomorrow.
- 她每天跑步。 = She runs every day.
So in your sentence, 每天 naturally comes before 来.
Why does the sentence use 来公园 and not 去公园?
Both 来 and 去 can sometimes be translated as to go, but they depend on perspective.
- 来 = come, movement toward the speaker or the reference point
- 去 = go, movement away from the speaker or reference point
In this sentence, 来公园 presents the action as coming to the park. This may reflect the speaker’s viewpoint, the location of the conversation, or simply a narrative choice.
In many real contexts, either 来 or 去 could appear depending on perspective:
- 每天来公园打篮球 = come to the park every day to play basketball
- 每天去公园打篮球 = go to the park every day to play basketball
So the choice is about viewpoint, not a different core action.
Why is it 打篮球 and not 玩篮球?
In Chinese, many sports use the verb 打.
So:
- 打篮球 = play basketball
- 打排球 = play volleyball
- 打网球 = play tennis
Even though 打 literally often means hit, in sports it commonly means play.
By contrast, 玩 is used more for:
- games
- toys
- general fun activities
So:
- 玩游戏 = play games
- 打篮球 = play basketball
That difference is very important and very common in Mandarin.
Why is it 玩游戏 but 打篮球? Both are translated as play in English.
This is one of those places where English uses one verb, but Chinese uses different verbs depending on the activity.
- 玩 is used for games / fun activities
- 打 is used for many ball sports
So:
- 玩游戏 = play games
- 打篮球 = play basketball
Other examples:
- 玩手机 = use / play on the phone
- 玩电脑游戏 = play computer games
- 打足球 is not standard; you say 踢足球 for soccer because you kick it
- 打乒乓球 = play table tennis
So the verb choice depends on the type of activity, not on the English word play.
Why is there no question mark at the end? Isn’t this a question?
It contains a question, but the whole sentence is actually reporting what the reporter asked.
The structure is:
- 记者又问她,为什么...
That means:
- The reporter asked her why...
So this is an indirect question, not a direct quoted question.
Compare:
- 记者又问她,为什么不在家玩游戏,而是每天来公园打篮球。
- The reporter again asked her why she didn’t stay home and play games, but instead came to the park every day to play basketball.
Direct question version:
- 记者又问她:你为什么不在家玩游戏,而是每天来公园打篮球?
- The reporter asked her: Why don’t you stay home and play games, but instead come to the park every day to play basketball?
So the period is fine in the original sentence.
What does 在家 mean exactly? Is it just at home?
Yes, 在家 means at home or staying at home.
- 在 = at / in
- 家 = home
So:
- 在家玩游戏 = play games at home
Chinese often uses 在 + place to show location:
- 在学校学习 = study at school
- 在公司上班 = work at the company
- 在公园散步 = take a walk in the park
Why doesn’t Chinese use words like the, a, or plural endings here?
Mandarin does not have articles like a or the, and nouns usually do not change form for singular/plural the way English nouns do.
So:
- 记者 can mean a reporter or the reporter
- 公园 can mean a park or the park
- 游戏 can mean game or games
The exact meaning comes from context.
In this sentence:
- 记者 is understood as the reporter because the context probably already introduced that person
- 公园 is understood as the park or simply the park area she goes to
- 玩游戏 naturally means play games
This is very normal in Chinese; context does a lot of the work that articles and plural endings do in English.
Can 为什么不在家玩游戏,而是每天来公园打篮球 be understood as a direct question to you, not just about her?
By itself, that clause could sound like a direct question such as:
- Why don’t you stay home and play games, but instead come to the park every day to play basketball?
But in this sentence, because it begins with:
- 记者又问她
the listener understands that the omitted subject belongs to her.
So in full meaning, it is:
- The reporter asked her why she didn’t stay home and play games, but instead came to the park every day to play basketball.
Chinese often leaves subjects unstated when context makes them obvious.
Is 问她,为什么... a common pattern in Mandarin?
Yes, very common.
Chinese often uses:
- 问 + person + question clause
Examples:
- 我问他,他为什么没来。
- I asked him why he didn’t come.
- 老师问我们,谁会回答这个问题。
- The teacher asked us who could answer this question.
- 她问我,什么时候出发。
- She asked me when we are leaving.
So your sentence follows a very standard pattern:
- 记者又问她,为什么...
Why is there a comma after 她?
The comma helps separate the main reporting clause from the content of what was asked.
- 记者又问她, = The reporter asked her,
- 为什么不在家玩游戏,而是每天来公园打篮球。 = the content of the question
Chinese punctuation often marks these clause boundaries clearly.
You can think of it like English:
- The reporter asked her, why not stay home and play games, but instead come to the park every day to play basketball?
Even though the exact punctuation conventions are not always identical between English and Chinese, the comma here is very natural in Chinese.
Is this sentence describing a habitual action because of 每天?
Yes.
每天 means every day, so it suggests a repeated or habitual action.
- 每天来公园打篮球 = comes to the park every day to play basketball
Without 每天, the sentence would just talk about the action more generally:
- 来公园打篮球 = come to the park to play basketball
With 每天, it clearly becomes a routine.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning ChineseMaster Chinese — from jìzhě yòu wèn tā, wèishénme bú zài jiā wán yóuxì, érshì měitiān lái gōngyuán dǎ lánqiú to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions