Breakdown of Si plantem aquesta llavor avui, potser podrem collir alguna cosa a la tardor.
Questions & Answers about Si plantem aquesta llavor avui, potser podrem collir alguna cosa a la tardor.
Why is it si plantem and not si plantarem?
In Catalan, after si meaning if, a real or possible future condition normally takes the present indicative, not the future.
So Catalan says:
- Si plantem aquesta llavor avui...
- literally: If we plant this seed today...
Even though the meaning refers to the future, the verb after si stays in the present. This is very common in Catalan and also in English: If we plant it today, we’ll harvest later, not If we will plant it...
What form is plantem?
Plantem is the 1st person plural present indicative of plantar:
- jo planto = I plant
- tu plantes = you plant
- ell/ella planta = he/she plants
- nosaltres plantem = we plant
- vosaltres planteu = you all plant
- ells/elles planten = they plant
So plantem means we plant.
Why does the sentence use podrem collir instead of just collirem?
Podrem collir means we may be able to harvest or we might harvest, depending on context.
- podrem = future of poder = we will be able to / we may be able to
- collir = to harvest, pick, gather
Using poder + infinitive makes the statement a bit less direct and more tentative than collirem.
Compare:
- collirem alguna cosa = we will harvest something
- podrem collir alguna cosa = we may / will be able to harvest something
Because the sentence also has potser = maybe/perhaps, the overall tone is cautious and uncertain.
What exactly does potser mean, and where can it go in the sentence?
Potser means maybe or perhaps.
In this sentence:
- potser podrem collir... = maybe we’ll be able to harvest...
It often goes before the verb phrase, but Catalan word order is fairly flexible. You could also hear:
- Si plantem aquesta llavor avui, podrem potser collir alguna cosa a la tardor.
But the version with potser before the future verb is more natural and common.
Also, potser does not force the subjunctive here. It works fine with the indicative.
What does alguna cosa mean? Why not just one word?
Alguna cosa is a very common Catalan expression meaning something.
It is made up of:
- alguna = some
- cosa = thing
So literally it is some thing, but as a fixed expression it simply means something.
In this sentence:
- collir alguna cosa = harvest something
It can sound a bit broad or indefinite, which fits the idea: we do not know exactly what we will get, only that we might get something.
Why is it aquesta llavor?
Because llavor is a feminine singular noun, the demonstrative has to agree with it.
- aquest = this, masculine singular
- aquesta = this, feminine singular
So:
- aquesta llavor = this seed
If the noun were masculine, you would use aquest instead.
What is the difference between llavor and semença or other words for seed?
Llavor is the normal everyday word for seed.
It is the most natural choice in a sentence like this about planting and harvesting. Learners should treat llavor as the basic word to know first.
Other words may exist in more technical, regional, or literary contexts, but llavor is the common standard word.
Why is it a la tardor? Does Catalan usually use an article with seasons?
Yes, very often.
La tardor means autumn/fall, and after the preposition a you usually get:
- a la tardor = in autumn
- a la primavera = in spring
- a l’estiu = in summer
- a l’hivern = in winter
So the article is normal here.
English often says in autumn without an article, but Catalan commonly uses a + article + season.
Can avui go somewhere else in the sentence?
Yes. Catalan allows some flexibility with adverbs like avui.
The given sentence:
- Si plantem aquesta llavor avui...
is perfectly natural.
But you could also say:
- Si avui plantem aquesta llavor...
Both mean the same thing. The choice is mostly about emphasis or rhythm.
- avui at the end of the clause can sound slightly more neutral
- avui earlier can emphasize today
How do you pronounce si and why doesn’t it have an accent?
Here si means if, and it is written without an accent.
That is different from:
- sí = yes
So:
- si plantem... = if we plant...
- sí = yes
This is an important spelling distinction in Catalan.
How do you pronounce ll in llavor and collir?
In standard Catalan, ll is traditionally a palatal sound, roughly similar to the lli sound in English million for many learners.
So:
- llavor
- collir
both contain that ll sound.
However, pronunciation can vary by dialect, and in some varieties it may sound closer to a y sound. For learners, the safest approach is:
- recognize ll as a special Catalan spelling
- aim for a soft ly-type sound at first
That will usually be understood well.
What does collir mean exactly? Is it only used for harvesting crops?
Collir can mean to harvest, but also more generally to pick or gather.
For example, it can be used for:
- harvesting crops
- picking fruit
- gathering flowers
In this sentence, because we are talking about planting a seed and waiting until autumn, collir is naturally understood as harvest.
Could Catalan also use the present instead of the future in the second part?
Sometimes yes, depending on style and context, but podrem is the most straightforward choice here.
The sentence uses:
- potser podrem collir... = maybe we’ll be able to harvest...
That clearly points to the future.
In everyday Catalan, the present can sometimes refer to the future, but in a sentence like this, the future tense sounds especially natural because it is talking about a later result.
Is this a conditional sentence? If so, what kind?
Yes. It is a real/open conditional: a condition that is possible and has a possible future result.
Structure:
- Si + present indicative
- main clause with future or another appropriate tense
So here:
- Si plantem aquesta llavor avui = if we plant this seed today
- potser podrem collir alguna cosa a la tardor = maybe we’ll be able to harvest something in autumn
This is the normal pattern for realistic future conditions in Catalan.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Si plantem aquesta llavor avui, potser podrem collir alguna cosa a la tardor to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions