Breakdown of El maig passat no vam sentir cap tro, però a l'abril sí que hi va haver una tempesta.
Questions & Answers about El maig passat no vam sentir cap tro, però a l'abril sí que hi va haver una tempesta.
Why does the sentence start with El maig passat? Why is there an article before the month?
In Catalan, months are often used with the definite article, especially when talking about a specific month in time.
So:
- el maig = May
- el maig passat = last May
This is very natural in Catalan. English usually says last May without an article, but Catalan commonly uses el.
Also, passat comes after the noun:
- el maig passat = last May
- literally: the May past
Why is it vam sentir and not just sentírem?
Vam sentir is the very common spoken and written past tense in Catalan, called the periphrastic past.
It is formed with:
- a form of anar (vaig, vas, va, vam, vau, van)
- plus the infinitive
So:
- vam sentir = we heard / we felt
This tense is extremely common in modern Catalan.
The simple past form sentírem also exists, but it is much less common in everyday language.
Why does sentir mean hear here? Doesn't it usually mean feel?
Yes, sentir can mean both to feel and to hear, depending on context.
In this sentence:
- vam sentir cap tro = we didn’t hear any thunder
Because tro means thunderclap / thunder, the meaning is clearly about hearing.
So sentir can cover:
- feel something physically or emotionally
- hear a sound
What does cap mean in no vam sentir cap tro?
Cap is often used in negative sentences to mean any or no.
So:
- no vam sentir cap tro = we didn’t hear any thunder
- literally: we didn’t hear any thunderclap
This is a very common Catalan structure:
- No tinc cap problema = I don’t have any problem
- No ve ningú / No hi ha cap persona = No one is coming / There isn’t any person
So after no, cap strengthens the negative idea.
Why is it cap tro and not caps trons?
After cap, Catalan usually uses a singular noun, even when English would often use a plural.
So:
- cap tro = any thunder / any thunderclap
- not usually caps trons
This is normal Catalan grammar:
- cap llibre = no books / not a single book
- cap idea = no idea
- cap problema = no problems
English and Catalan behave differently here.
Why is it a l'abril?
This is just the preposition a plus the article l' before a vowel sound:
- a + l'abril → a l'abril
It means:
- in April
Catalan often uses a with months in time expressions:
- al maig
- a l'abril
- al juny
So però a l'abril means but in April.
What does sí que mean here?
Sí que adds emphasis or contrast. It is like saying:
- did
- actually did
- did indeed
So:
- però a l'abril sí que hi va haver una tempesta
means something like:
- but in April there was a storm
- but in April there really was a storm
- but in April there actually was a storm
Here it contrasts with the first part:
- In May, we didn’t hear any thunder
- but in April, there definitely was a storm
So sí que is not just yes; it is an emphatic contrast marker.
Why does it say hi va haver instead of just va haver?
In this sentence, hi ha / hi havia / hi va haver is the Catalan existential structure meaning there is / there was / there were.
So:
- hi ha una tempesta = there is a storm
- hi havia una tempesta = there was a storm
- hi va haver una tempesta = there was a storm
The hi is an essential part of this structure.
So hi va haver una tempesta does not mean it had a storm. It means there was a storm.
Why is it una tempesta if English would often say just there was a storm without much emphasis on the article?
Catalan normally uses the indefinite article with a singular countable noun here, just as English does:
- una tempesta = a storm
This is completely regular:
- hi va haver un accident = there was an accident
- hi ha un problema = there is a problem
So una tempesta is simply the normal way to say a storm.
Why is the word order sí que hi va haver una tempesta?
This follows a very natural Catalan order:
- sí que = emphatic contrast
- hi va haver = there was
- una tempesta = a storm
So the structure is:
[contrast/emphasis] + [existential verb] + [thing that existed]
Catalan word order is often a bit more fixed than English in this kind of sentence.
Putting sí que before the verb phrase is the normal way to emphasize the contrast.
Is tro exactly the same as thunder in English?
Almost, but it helps to know the nuance.
Tro can mean:
- thunder
- a thunderclap
- the sound of thunder
In this sentence, cap tro means any thunder or any thunderclap.
So the idea is not about lightning in general, but specifically the sound associated with a storm.
Why is però used here instead of another word for but?
Però is the normal Catalan word for but.
So:
- ..., però ... = ..., but ...
It links two contrasting ideas:
- last May, no thunder
- but in April, there was a storm
It is the most straightforward and common choice here.
Could the sentence use hi havia instead of hi va haver?
Yes, but the meaning would be slightly different in tone or aspect.
- hi va haver una tempesta = there was a storm
This presents the storm as a completed event. - hi havia una tempesta = there was a storm / there used to be a storm / there was a storm going on
This can sound more descriptive or ongoing, depending on context.
In this sentence, hi va haver fits well because it refers to a specific event in April.
Can el maig passat also be said as el passat mes de maig?
Yes, but the tone is different.
- el maig passat is the normal, simple everyday expression: last May
- el passat mes de maig is more formal or elaborate: the past month of May
So for ordinary speech and writing, el maig passat is the most natural choice.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from El maig passat no vam sentir cap tro, però a l'abril sí que hi va haver una tempesta to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions