Breakdown of Hi ha un cargol a terra, al costat de la galleda que hem posat sota l'aixeta.
Questions & Answers about Hi ha un cargol a terra, al costat de la galleda que hem posat sota l'aixeta.
Hi ha is the standard Catalan way to say there is or there are.
- Hi ha un cargol = There is a snail / a screw
- literally, hi is a locative element and ha comes from haver
You do not use és here, because és means is in the sense of identifying or describing something:
- És un cargol = It is a snail / screw
And està is used for location or state of something already known:
- El cargol està a terra = The snail / screw is on the ground
So:
- Hi ha... = introducing that something exists or is present
- És... = identifying what something is
- Està... = saying where something is
Catalan usually uses an article with singular countable nouns in this kind of sentence, just like English does.
- un cargol = a snail / a screw
Leaving out the article would sound unnatural here. In existential sentences with hi ha, Catalan normally says:
- Hi ha un llibre sobre la taula
- Hi ha una cadira aquí