Question 1

Why can we use a zu infinitive clause here instead of a dass clause?

Accepted Answer

This is because of "object identity." The verb ermutigen takes the accusative object den Sopran. Since the person being encouraged (the object of the main clause) is the exact same person who will do the singing (the subject of the infinitive clause), we don't need a clunky dass clause. We can just drop the subject in the second half and use a zu infinitive!

Question 2

How would this sentence look if we had to use dass?

Accepted Answer

It would be: Ich ermutige den Sopran, dass er den hohen Ton singt. Because we use dass, we are forced to explicitly name the subject (er) and conjugate the verb (singt) at the end of the clause. The version with zu singen means exactly the same thing but is much more natural and elegant.

Question 3

Wait, why is it den Sopran? Is a soprano masculine?

Accepted Answer

Yes! Even though a soprano is almost always a female singer, the musical voice type itself is masculine in German (der Sopran). Since the soprano is the direct object receiving the encouragement, we use the masculine accusative den Sopran. (This is also why we would use the pronoun er to refer back to her in a dass clause!)

Question 4

Why does the adjective hoch change to hohen in den hohen Ton?

Accepted Answer

Ton (note or sound) is masculine, and it's the direct object of singen, putting it in the accusative case (den). After a definite article like den, adjectives take the weak ending -en. Additionally, hoch is slightly irregular: it drops the "c" whenever an ending is added, which is why it becomes hohen rather than "hochen".

Ich ermutige den Sopran, den hohen Ton zu singen.

Breakdown of Ich ermutige den Sopran, den hohen Ton zu singen.

Questions & Answers about Ich ermutige den Sopran, den hohen Ton zu singen.

Learn Ich ermutige den Sopran, den hohen Ton zu singen and more in German