Question 1

Why is the verb singular (gibt) when it refers to plural participants?

Accepted Answer

The phrase es gibt (there is / there are) is a fixed expression. The grammatical subject is the singular pronoun es, which is why the verb is conjugated as gibt. The phrase viele Teilnehmer is actually the direct object.

Question 2

Since viele Teilnehmer is the direct object, what case is it in?

Accepted Answer

It is in the accusative case! The expression es gibt always requires the accusative. Because Teilnehmer is plural, the accusative looks exactly like the nominative, but remembering this rule is crucial when dealing with masculine singular nouns.

Question 3

How do we know that Teilnehmer is plural here?

Accepted Answer

Most masculine and neuter nouns that end in -er do not change their spelling in the plural. You have to look at the surrounding words to tell the difference. Here, the plural word viele (many) makes it clear that we are talking about multiple participants.

Question 4

Why is there no article before Smartphone? Shouldn't it be ohne ein Smartphone?

Accepted Answer

While ohne ein Smartphone is grammatically correct, German often drops the indefinite article (ein / eine) after the preposition ohne. This is very common when talking about things in a general sense or as a category, rather than a specific object.

Question 5

We're learning about nominalized infinitives (verbs turned into nouns). Is Teilnehmer an example of this?

Accepted Answer

Not exactly. A nominalized infinitive uses the exact infinitive form of the verb with a capital letter, like das Teilnehmen (the participating). Der Teilnehmer is a noun built from the verb teilnehmen, but it uses the -er ending to describe the person doing the action, similar to adding -er in English.

Es gibt viele Teilnehmer ohne Smartphone.

Breakdown of Es gibt viele Teilnehmer ohne Smartphone.

Questions & Answers about Es gibt viele Teilnehmer ohne Smartphone.

Learn Es gibt viele Teilnehmer ohne Smartphone and more in German