Log inSign up

Il n'y a pas de train, mais il y a un avion.

Il n'y a pas de train, mais il y a un avion.
There is no train, but there is a plane.
From Lesson 21:Yes/no questions with "Est-ce que" (Est-ce que tu parles ?)·French

Questions & Answers about Il n'y a pas de train, mais il y a un avion.

How would I ask "Is there a train?" using "est-ce que" like in this lesson?
To turn this into a yes/no question, you put est-ce que right before il y a. Because il starts with a vowel, que drops its 'e' and becomes qu'. So, "Is there a train?" becomes Est-ce qu'il y a un train ?
How does "il y a" (there is) become negative in the first half of the sentence?
To make a verb negative in French, you put ne and pas around it. In the phrase il y a, the actual verb is a (has), but the y and the a stick together. Because y acts like a vowel sound here, ne shrinks to n'. This gives us il n'y a pas (there is not / there is no).
Why does it say "pas de train" instead of "pas un train"?
This is a very common French rule that trips up beginners! In a negative sentence, the words for "a", "an", or "some" (un, une, des) almost always change to de. Because the first half of the sentence is negative, un train must change to de train.
Why does the second part say "un avion" and not "d'avion"?
The second part of the sentence is positive ("but there is a plane"). The rule about changing un to de only happens after a negative phrase. Since this part is positive, you just use the normal word for "a", which is un.

Learn Il n'y a pas de train, mais il y a un avion and more in French

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
  • ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free
Start learning French →