When a relative clause combines a preposition with possession, as in English with whose proposal, in whose car or to the success of which, Afrikaans uses two structures depending on what the clause refers back to. For people, use [preposition] + wie se + [noun]. For things and abstract concepts, use [preposition] + die [noun] waarvan.
People: [preposition] + wie se + [noun]
When the antecedent is a person (die kollega, die direkteur, die vrou), put the preposition directly before wie se (whose), followed by the possessed noun:
- Structure: there is no article before the possessed noun (die kollega met wie se voorstel ek saamstem, the colleague with whose proposal I agree). An adjective takes its normal attributive form (met wie se belangrike doelstellings, with whose important objectives).
- Choosing the preposition: it comes either from the meaning, such as by (at), in, sonder (without), binne (within) or volgens (according to), or from a verb's fixed preposition: skryf oor (write about) gives oor wie se … skryf, and saamstem met (agree with) gives met wie se … saamstem.
- Word order: as in other relative clauses, the verbs go to the end of the clause (… in wie se motor ons gery het), and a separable verb is written as one word there (… saamstem). After the comma, the main clause continues with its own verb straight away. Separable verbs split as usual in the main clause: Die vrou in wie se motor ons gery het, bied haar ondersteuning aan (from aanbied, to offer).
Useful words: navorser (researcher), skenker (donor), misluk (to fail), adviseur (advisor), beleid (policy), kenner (expert), voorstel (proposal).
Things and concepts: [preposition] + die [noun] waarvan
Wie se is used for people. For things and abstract concepts (die projek, 'n inisiatief, die beleid, 'n stelsel), Afrikaans switches to waarvan (of which). It comes after the possessed noun. English can also say whose for things (the project to whose success everyone contributed), but Afrikaans does not use wie se here.
- Structure: [preposition] + die [noun] + waarvan. The possessed noun takes die, and waarvan follows it immediately (die projek tot die sukses waarvan almal bygedra het, the project to the success of which everyone contributed).
- Choosing the preposition: usually it comes from an expression inside the clause. Bydra tot gives tot die sukses waarvan. Saamstem met gives met die doelstellings waarvan. Verantwoordelik wees vir gives vir die implementering waarvan. Onsekerheid oor gives oor die uitwerking waarvan. Afhang van gives van die sukses waarvan. Sometimes it comes from the meaning instead, as with tydens (during): tydens die implementering waarvan.
- Word order: after waarvan, the verbs go to the end. Separable verbs are written as one word there (… saamstem, … dophou, … afhang). In the perfect, the ge- goes between prefix and verb (bydra → … bygedra het).
Useful words: vorder (to progress), inisiatief (initiative), ten volle (fully), onsekerheid (uncertainty), heers (to prevail), deeglik (thoroughly), dophou (to monitor), immers (after all), gemeenskap (community).
Summary
| Antecedent | Pattern | Example |
|---|
| Person | [preposition] + wie se + [noun] | die vrou in wie se motor ons gery het |
| Thing / concept | [preposition] + die [noun] waarvan | die beleid oor die uitwerking waarvan daar nog onsekerheid heers |