Afrikaans has three modifiers for shades of doubt, strong negation and open alternatives: enigsins (at all / in any way), allesbehalwe (anything but / far from) and the formal al dan nie (whether or not). You'll practise them while discussing space exploration and judging whether new telescope data is conclusive.
Doubt and conditions: enigsins
In this lesson, enigsins means at all or in any way. It appears where something is uncertain or open:
- Indirect questions with of (whether): after verbs of asking, knowing or doubting, such as weet of (know whether), twyfel of (doubt whether) and dit bly onduidelik of (it remains unclear whether).
- Conditions with as (if): if … at all, as in as dit enigsins moontlik is (if it is at all possible).
In negated clauses, nie enigsins … nie means not at all and keeps its closing nie: Ek is nie enigsins moeg nie. In a plain positive statement, enigsins means somewhat: Hy is enigsins verbaas (He is somewhat surprised).
Word order:
- Verb to the end after of and as: both are subordinating conjunctions, so the finite verb goes to the end of the clause, after enigsins: … of daar enigsins lewe elders in die heelal bestaan.
- Fronted as-clause: the main clause after the comma inverts to verb + subject, and an infinitive such as waarneem (observe) goes to the end: As dit enigsins moontlik is, wil hy … waarneem.
Note bewoonbaar (habitable), which becomes bewoonbare before a noun (bewoonbare planete). In stuur vir my (send me), vir marks the recipient.
Strong negation without a closing nie: allesbehalwe
allesbehalwe (anything but, far from) is written as one word (alles, everything, + behalwe, except). It usually comes directly before the adjective it modifies:
- allesbehalwe tevrede: anything but satisfied
- allesbehalwe deurslaggewend: anything but conclusive
- allesbehalwe oortuigend: far from convincing
No closing nie: allesbehalwe is close in meaning to glad nie … nie (not at all), but grammatically the clause is affirmative. It takes no closing nie: Sy is allesbehalwe tevrede, never … tevrede nie.
Note the verb-second inversion after a fronted phrase: Volgens die navorser is … (According to the researcher, … is).
In formal, academic and scientific Afrikaans, al dan nie (or not) pairs with of (whether) to weigh two possibilities:
- Position: it usually comes at the end of the of-clause, after the clause-final verb: … of die bevinding deurslaggewend is al dan nie. It can also come earlier, before the predicate: … of die bevinding al dan nie deurslaggewend is.
- No extra nie: the nie in al dan nie already completes the negative alternative, so no second nie is added.
Two common patterns:
- After verbs of determining: vasstel of (establish whether) or om te bepaal of (in order to determine whether).
- Fronted concessive clause (Whether … or not, …): Of [subject] nou … is al dan nie, … The particle nou is idiomatic here. Unlike a fronted as-clause, this clause normally leaves the main clause in subject + verb order: Of haar bewering nou waar is al dan nie, ons moet die ruimte verder verken.
Quick summary
| Expression | Meaning | Position | Closing nie? |
|---|
| enigsins | at all, in any way | In questions, of-clauses and as-clauses, before the adjective or verb | Only if the clause itself is negated |
| allesbehalwe | anything but, far from | Directly before the adjective | No |
| of … al dan nie | whether … or not | Usually at the end of the of-clause, after the verb | Built into al dan nie (no extra nie) |