Question 1

How exactly do the suffixes on birbirimizin work here?

Accepted Answer

The base word is birbiri (each other). Since the sentence is about "we" doing the action, we first add the "our" suffix to get birbirimiz (our each other). Finally, because we are talking about each other's ideas, we add the genitive (possessive) case -in to make it birbirimizin (each other's).

Question 2

If it is "our" each other's ideas (birbirimizin), why does fikirlerini use the 3rd person possessive (-i) instead of "our" (-imiz)?

Accepted Answer

This is a tricky but important rule! Even though we say birbirimiz to show that we are doing the action, the word birbiri acts like a 3rd person owner grammatically. So, just like you would say Ali's ideas (Ali'nin fikirleri), you say each other's ideas (birbirimizin fikirleri).

Question 3

Why is there an extra "-ni" at the end of fikirlerini?

Accepted Answer

Let's break it down: fikir-ler-i gives us "the ideas of" (belonging to each other). The verb tartışmak (to discuss) requires its specific direct object to take the accusative case. So we add the buffer letter -n- and the accusative suffix -i to point out exactly what we are discussing, creating fikirlerini.

Question 4

Can tartışıyoruz also mean "we are arguing"?

Accepted Answer

Yes! The verb tartışmak translates to "to discuss" or "to debate", but it is also the standard word for "to argue" (verbally). You have to rely on the context to know if it is a calm exchange of ideas or a heated argument.

Sadece birbirimizin fikirlerini tartışıyoruz.

Breakdown of Sadece birbirimizin fikirlerini tartışıyoruz.

Questions & Answers about Sadece birbirimizin fikirlerini tartışıyoruz.

Learn Sadece birbirimizin fikirlerini tartışıyoruz and more in Turkish