Breakdown of Как мы ни наказываем кота, он продолжает грызть ботинки.
кот
cat
он
he / it (for a masculine noun) / it (for a neuter noun)
мы
we
как
how
продолжать
to continue
ботинок
boot, sturdy shoe
ни
not (negative particle in ни с кем, ни о чём)
наказывать
to punish
грызть
to chew
Questions & Answers about Как мы ни наказываем кота, он продолжает грызть ботинки.
Why is there a ни here instead of не? Doesn't that make it negative?
In Russian, the structure как ни plus a verb means 'no matter how'. The ни here does not negate the action. Instead, it acts as an intensifier to express a concession. It means we actually do punish the cat, but despite our efforts, the result doesn't change.
Could we use the perfective verb накажем instead of the imperfective наказываем in this structure?
Because the second half of the sentence uses продолжает (continues), we are talking about a repeated or ongoing situation. The imperfective наказываем perfectly matches this idea: we punish him again and again. While perfective is possible in как ни constructions for single completed actions, the imperfective is needed here for the repeated context.
Why is грызть (to chew) imperfective? Could a perfective verb work here?
No, you cannot use a perfective verb here. In Russian, verbs that describe starting, continuing, or finishing an action, such as продолжать, must always be followed by an imperfective infinitive. This is because they inherently focus on the ongoing process of the action.
Why does the direct object кота end in -а, while the other direct object ботинки looks just like the nominative?
Both words are in the accusative case, but Russian treats them differently based on animacy. Кот (cat) is an animate noun, so its accusative form matches the genitive (кота). Ботинки (boots) is an inanimate noun, so its accusative plural form matches the nominative plural.
Learn Как мы ни наказываем кота, он продолжает грызть ботинки and more in Russian
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free