When talking about artisanal cheesemaking (a produção de queijo artesanal) and how producers balance traditional methods with modern quality standards, you often need to link three kinds of ideas: actions that happen at the same moment, activities that run side by side, or two contrasting truths. Brazilian Portuguese does this in two ways:
- With the clause connector ao mesmo tempo (em) que, followed by a clause.
- With the prepositional phrases simultaneamente a and paralelamente a, followed by a noun.
Simultaneous actions: ao mesmo tempo que and ao mesmo tempo em que
To connect two clauses whose actions happen at the same time, use ao mesmo tempo que or ao mesmo tempo em que (at the same time that / while).
- With or without em? Both forms are standard and interchangeable in Brazilian Portuguese.
- What follows: Because they end in que, they introduce a clause with a conjugated verb.
- Key vocabulary: o laticínio (the dairy product), a maturação (the aging / the maturation), a casca (the rind), a técnica (the technique), o método (the method).
Paradoxical contrast: ao mesmo tempo (em) que at the start of a sentence
When ao mesmo tempo (em) que opens a sentence, it often goes beyond literal timing. It expresses a paradoxical contrast: two facts that are both true at once, even when they pull in different directions (At the same time that... / While...).
- Structure: Ao mesmo tempo (em) que
- first clause, + second clause. A comma separates the two clauses.
- Key vocabulary: o leite cru (raw milk), a higiene (the hygiene), rigoroso / rigorosa (rigorous / strict), a inspeção (the inspection).
Simultaneous processes with nouns: simultaneamente a
Ao mesmo tempo (em) que introduces a clause. Simultaneamente a (simultaneously with) is different: it links an action to a noun, meaning a process, check, or event happening at the same moment.
Contractions with a: The expression ends with the preposition a, so it contracts with the definite article of the noun that follows:
- a + o = ao
- a + a = à
- a + os = aos
- a + as = às
For example: simultaneamente ao controle, simultaneamente à fermentação.
- Placement: The whole phrase (simultaneamente a
- noun) can open the sentence, followed by a comma, or come after the main verb.
- Key vocabulary: a fermentação (the fermentation), a umidade (the humidity), o fiscal (the inspector), a vistoria (the official inspection).
Parallel pursuits and practices: paralelamente a
Paralelamente a (in parallel with / alongside) is also followed by a noun and takes the same contractions (ao, à, aos, às). It doesn't point to a single shared moment. Instead, it describes ongoing activities, projects, or methods that run side by side over a period of time.
- Placement: The whole phrase (paralelamente a
- noun) can open the sentence, followed by a comma, or come after the main clause.
- Key vocabulary: lidar com (to deal with), a distribuição (the distribution), a análise (the analysis).
Summary
| Expression | Followed by | Meaning & Use | Example |
|---|
| ao mesmo tempo (em) que | Clause (conjugated verb) | at the same time that / while (simultaneous actions) | Helena avalia o laticínio ao mesmo tempo que controla a maturação. |
| Ao mesmo tempo (em) que..., ... | Clause, then a comma and the main clause | At the same time that / While (paradoxical contrast) | Ao mesmo tempo que o leite cru traz sabor, ele exige higiene rigorosa. |
| simultaneamente a (ao / à / aos / às) | Noun phrase | simultaneously with (events at the same moment) | Simultaneamente à fermentação, a maturação desenvolve a textura do queijo. |
| paralelamente a (ao / à / aos / às) | Noun phrase | in parallel with / alongside (ongoing parallel pursuits) | Ela estuda novas técnicas paralelamente ao trabalho na fazenda. |