Word
Ten pisarz okazał się skandalistą i oszustem.
Meaning
This writer turned out to be a scandalist and a fraud.
Part of speech
sentence
Pronunciation
Course
Breakdown of Ten pisarz okazał się skandalistą i oszustem.
i
and
ten
this (m)
pisarz
writer
okazać się
to turn out (perf)
Questions & Answers about Ten pisarz okazał się skandalistą i oszustem.
Why are the words "skandalistą" and "oszustem" in the Instrumental case here?
The verb okazać się (to turn out to be) governs the Instrumental case for the noun phrase that follows it. It behaves just like the verbs być (to be) and stać się (to become) when equating a person to a noun or a role.
Why does "skandalistą" have a feminine ending (-ą) if the writer is a man, while "oszustem" has a standard masculine ending (-em)?
The base word is skandalista. Even though it describes a man, it ends in -a in the Nominative case (just like mężczyzna or kolega). Masculine nouns ending in -a decline like feminine nouns in the singular, which is why it takes the feminine Instrumental ending -ą.
Why is the perfective verb "okazał się" used here instead of the imperfective "okazywał się"?
Okazał się focuses on the final, one-time realization or the permanent outcome: the moment it was finally revealed that he was a fraud. If you used the imperfective okazywał się, it would imply a repeated process, meaning he kept turning out to be a fraud over multiple separate occasions.
If I wanted to drop the nouns and just use an adjective, like "This writer turned out to be controversial", would it still be in the Instrumental case?
No, and this is a common trap! When okazać się is followed by a noun (like in this sentence), you use the Instrumental. But if it is followed only by an adjective, that adjective normally stays in the Nominative case. For example: Ten pisarz okazał się kontrowersyjny.