When the second action has the same subject as the main clause, Norwegian uses å + infinitive after uten and i stedet for. When the subject changes, it switches to at + a full clause (subject + finite verb).
Uten å vs. uten at
- Same subject: uten å
- infinitive, without doing
- New subject: uten at
- subject + finite verb, without [someone] doing
Same subject. He leaves, and he doesn't say goodbye; you close the door, and you don't make noise:
| He left without saying goodbye. | Han gikk uten å si ha det. |
| Can you close the door at night without making noise? | Kan du lukke døra om natta uten å bråke? |
New subject. He leaves, but we don't notice:
| He left without us noticing it. | Han gikk uten at vi merket det. |
| She took my milk without me noticing it. | Hun tok melka mi uten at jeg merket det. |
| We would like to sleep without anyone making noise in the shared flat. | Vi vil gjerne sove uten at noen bråker i kollektivet. |
| You have to tidy the kitchen without me having to nag. | Du må rydde kjøkkenet uten at jeg må mase. |
Two things to watch with uten at:
- Subject pronouns: English often uses an object pronoun + -ing (without me noticing, without us nagging). Uten at introduces a full clause, so Norwegian uses the subject pronoun (jeg, du, han, hun, vi, de): uten at jeg merket det, uten at vi maser på henne.
- Finite verb: The verb is conjugated and follows the tense of the situation: present (uten at noen bråker), past (uten at vi merket det) or with a modal (uten at jeg må mase).
Useful words:
- en romkamerat (a flatmate, a roommate), romkameraten, plural romkamerater
- et kollektiv (a shared flat), kollektivet
- å merke (to notice), past merket
- ei melk (milk), melka
- ei dør (a door), døra; ei natt (a night), natta
- å bråke (to make noise), past bråket
- å mase (to nag); å mase på noen (to nag someone)
- å rote (to make a mess), past rotet
I stedet for å vs. i stedet for at
The same rule applies to instead of:
- Same subject: i stedet for å
- infinitive, instead of doing
- New subject: i stedet for at
- subject + finite verb, instead of [someone] doing
Same subject:
| Why does he throw everything together instead of sorting the trash? | Hvorfor kaster han alt sammen i stedet for å sortere søpla? |
| Put the cup in the dishwasher instead of putting it in the sink. | Sett koppen i oppvaskmaskinen i stedet for å sette den i vasken. |
In a command like Sett koppen..., the understood subject of Sett is du. The same person does both actions, so you use i stedet for å.
New subject:
| We keep the living room tidy instead of everyone making a mess. | Vi holder stua ryddig i stedet for at alle roter. |
| Everyone must sort the trash instead of only me doing it. | Alle må sortere søpla i stedet for at bare jeg gjør det. |
| We share the housework instead of her doing everything alone. | Vi deler husarbeidet i stedet for at hun gjør alt alene. |
| You should empty the sink now instead of me having to do it later. | Du bør tømme vasken nå i stedet for at jeg må gjøre det senere. |
- Pronouns with bare: Even with bare (only) in front, the pronoun is the subject of the clause and keeps its subject form: i stedet for at bare jeg gjør det (instead of only me doing it), i stedet for at hun gjør alt alene (instead of her doing everything alone).
- Gjøre det: English uses doing it to avoid repeating a verb phrase, and Norwegian does the same with gjøre det: i stedet for at jeg må gjøre det senere.
Useful words:
- en vask (a sink), vasken
- en oppvaskmaskin (a dishwasher), oppvaskmaskinen
- ei stue (a living room), stua
- ei søppel (trash, rubbish), søpla
- å sortere (to sort), past sorterte
- å tømme (to empty), past tømte
- et husarbeid (housework), husarbeidet
Your questions are stored by us to improve Elon.io
